Hi folks, Was discussing with one of the listmasters (Alexander Wirt) on IRC today about mailing list bans, because it turns out that someone I was just about to ask the listmasters to ban from debian-devel had just been blocked in response to a request from someone else. This led to a philosophical debate about whether bans should be made public. Alexander expressed concern that having them published could be harmful to a person's reputation, since employers will google your name and see that you've been banned from a large project such as Debian. I think we should publish them, for several reasons: - Debian is not responsible for the reputation of someone who has gotten themselves banned for their behavior; their reputation is already in the mud if employers read their actual posts to the Debian lists. - It brings closure to the rest of our community to know that action has been taken against an abuser, showing that we've stood up for the principle of civil discourse and that the problem hasn't just gone away on its own because a troll got bored. - It gives Debian contributors confidence that bad behavior doesn't have to be silently endured as a cost of participating in Debian lists. - It improves *Debian's* reputation to the rest of the world, by showing that our mailing lists are not "anything goes". - It provides a reference point for newcomers to the Debian community to judge their actions by, to understand what kinds of things will get them banned from participation (although I expect few of the people who need such guidance will actually take advantage of it...) - It casts sunlight on the kinds of decisions that the listmasters are making WRT bans, so that we collectively have oversight of these decisions and can ensure our principles are being applied fairly and consistently. So I don't think bans need to be posted anywhere prominent like debian-devel-announce, but I do think basic facts like who is banned, for how long, and the rationale (with links to specific mailing list posts as reference) should be made public. What do the rest of you think? Cheers, -- Steve Langasek Give me a lever long enough and a Free OS Debian Developer to set it on, and I can move the world. Ubuntu Developer http://www.debian.org/ slangasek@ubuntu.com vorlon@debian.org
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: Digital signature