[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: Amendement to GR Statement regarding Stallman's readmission to the FSF board

El 30/03/21 a las 10:25, Milan Kupcevic escribió:
> On 3/30/21 10:10 AM, Zlatan Todoric wrote:
> > Hi Phil,
> > 
> > On 3/30/21 14:15, Phil Morrell wrote:
> >>> Therefore, in the current situation, the Debian Project is unable to
> >>> collaborate both with the FSF and any other organisation in which
> >>> Richard
> >>> Stallman has a leading position.
> >> Hi Santiago,
> >>
> >> I know this is more of a question about the original FSFE statement with
> >> this phrasing, but since you're amending it anyway I was wondering if
> >> you could expand upon the scope of this collaboration? preferably in the
> >> amendment text, but I understand if a list reply is more suitable.
> >>
> >> I'm not aware of any project level (i.e. funding, hardware or emails)
> >> interaction with the FSF, given the minor disagreement over the non-free
> >> archive. What about the GNU project? Are you asking DDs to only
> >> communicate and submit patches in a personal capacity? "unable to
> >> collaborate" implies there was collaboration before, so what exactly
> >> would the Debian project stop doing?
> > 
> > Good question, we could probably amend that part with:
> > 
> > "Therefore, in the current situation, the Debian Project discourages
> > collaboration both with the FSF and any other organisation in which
> > Richard Stallman has a leading position."
> > 
> I would support this amendment.

For the matter of consistency, this is the full amended amendment:

Choice X: Debian encourages working with groups that foster diversity
and equality

=== Begin text ===

Under section 4.1.5 of the constitution, the Developers make the following

Debian’s statement on Richard Stallman rejoining the FSF board

We at Debian are profoundly disappointed to hear of the re-election of Richard
Stallman to a leadership position at the Free Software Foundation, after a
series of serious accusations of misconduct led to his resignation as
president and board member of the FSF in 2019.

One crucial factor in making our community more inclusive is to recognise and
reflect when other people are harmed by our actions and consider this feedback
in future actions. Unfortunately, the way Richard Stallman announced his
return to the board lacks any acknowledgement of this kind of thought process.
We are deeply disappointed that the FSF board elected him as a board member
again, despite no discernible steps were taken by him to be accountable for,
much less make amends for, his past actions or those who have been harmed by
them. Finally, we are also disturbed by the secretive process of his
re-election, and how it was belatedly conveyed [0] to FSF’s staff and

We believe this step and how it was communicated sends a wrong and hurtful
message and harms the future of the Free Software movement. The goal of the
software freedom movement is to empower all people to control technology and
thereby create a better society for everyone. Free Software is meant to serve
everyone regardless of their age, ability or disability, gender identity, sex,
ethnicity, nationality, religion or sexual orientation. This requires an
inclusive and diverse environment that welcomes all contributors equally.
Debian realises that we and the Free Software movement still have to work hard
to be in that place where everyone feels safe and respected to participate in
it in order to fulfil the movement's mission.

Therefore, in the current situation, the Debian Project discourages
collaborating both with the FSF and any other organisation in which
Richard Stallman has a leading position. Instead, we will continue
looking forward to work with groups and individuals who foster diversity
and equality in the Free Software movement in order to achieve our joint
goal of empowering all users to control technology.

[0] https://status.fsf.org/notice/3796703

=== End text ===

Zlatan & Santiago

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: PGP signature

Reply to: