Re: Feedback on 3.0 source format problems
On Jan 04 2017, Vincent Bernat <email@example.com> wrote:
> ❦ 4 janvier 2017 04:52 GMT, Scott Kitterman <firstname.lastname@example.org> :
>>>> It's surprisingly awkward, and, at least for me, it turns out that
>>>> externalizing my rebased branch as a patch series solves many of
>>>> problems surprisingly well. All the other solutions I can think of
>>>> require one or more things I don't really want to do: rebase the
>>>> debian/master branch, not be able to run dpkg-buildpackage from the
>>>> debian/master branch easily, or require that dpkg-buildpackage do
>>>> more mucking about with source control than I want it to.
>>>I believe the git-dpm approach would give you everything you want. The
>>>explanation on http://git-dpm.alioth.debian.org/ is pretty good.
>>>I personally think that technically git-dpm's approach is the best -
>>>unfortunately the program itself is effectively unmaintained and
>>>apparently/consequently not used by many people.
>> The Debian Python Modules Team (DPMT) has about 1,000 packages with
>> git-dpm repositories. While it took a bit of getting used to and
>> there have been a few problems, overall I think it's worked very well.
>> It's biggest problem is the lack of a maintainer.
> There have been a lot of complaints about it. For me, it is a pain to
> use. Its integration with gbp is poor,
Well, I think that is because it is mostly an *alternative* to
gbp. Other than gbp dch (which I think should work fine), what features
of gbp would you like to use with git-dpm?
> Since we started using it, we opened a lot of bug reports and not a
> single one of them has been fixed. I think that nobody wants to work
> on it because it is an extremely fragile tool and the first one to try
> to fix it will inherit of all the problems to solve.
Yes, I think that falls under "lack of a maintainer".
> Isn't "gbp pq" a correct execution of the same principles?
No, absolutely not.
GPG encrypted emails preferred. Key id: 0xD113FCAC3C4E599F
Fingerprint: ED31 791B 2C5C 1613 AF38 8B8A D113 FCAC 3C4E 599F
»Time flies like an arrow, fruit flies like a Banana.«