[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: Responses to the list

Antony Gelberg wrote:
Mike McCarty wrote:

Ron Johnson wrote:

On Fri, 2005-09-23 at 12:25 -0400, Angelo Bertolli wrote:

Ron Johnson wrote:

If you send question to the list, you should expect the answer
to only go to the list.

Ok, now I'm confused.  I've seen so much "respond this way" on the
list lately.  I'm using Tbird, and when I hit "reply" it replies to
the poster only.  When I hit "reply-all" it goes to the poster, the
list, and maybe a few others that got picked up along the way.  I
thought this was done on purpose so as not to munge email headers
with mailman, but... now I've seen people say:

1) CC me because I'm not on the list (ok done - hit reply-all)
2) Respond to the list and don't CC me

So in this case, do we hit reply-all, and cut and paste the list
email as the To: line, removing all others, etc?

It seems to me if this is the behavior desired, then the mail headers
should be munged in mailman like so many others lists do.

Doesn't T-bird have a "Reply to list" option?

It does NOT.

And the way this echo is set up is a fairly irritating annoyance to me.

If I do a "Reply" as is my custom, then I have to switch to another
window, right-click to copy the list e-mail address, switch back,
click on another "To" and right-click to paste it in.

And if I don't notice, then the reply goes only to the originator.
So then I have to go to the "Sent" folder, find the message, and
forward it to the list.

Either one also messes up threaded reading.

But, I was told that this has all been hashed out before, so I guess
there are those who just don't care or don't know about what it costs
others to use the list.

Your guess is wide of the mark.  Just because things aren't how you want
them, the admins don't care?  What about people who _do_ want it this way?

Could this thread please die, now, immediately? Before a flame war gets

If you are upset about all the clicking and window changing, perhaps you
should consider a console-based mail client.

It woudn't help. The clicking is less effort than, say Pine, would be.
Pine has the same two options.

I am using Thunderbird right now, and the whole GUI-ness is a pain, but
I don't feel it with regard to this problem, as I have it set up to read
this list via the newsgroup linux.debian.user.  Hitting reply goes to
the group.  Perhaps this is something that some Thunderbird users should

GUIness is not the issue. The issue is the way replies work or do not
work, as one's viewpoint is.

The Mozilla apps go a great way to making Linux usable for ex-Windows
users, and they are fine work, but let's not pretend that they aren't
full of bugs.

Another option for those who don't like the list policy is to become
Debian Developers and change the policy.

Another option is for the thread to die before people start calling each
other Nazis.

This message made from 100% recycled bits.
You have found the bank of Larn.
I can explain it for you, but I can't understand it for you.
I speak only for myself, and I am unanimous in that!

Reply to: