[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: Adobe open source license -- is this licence free?

On Thu, Jan 26, 2006 at 01:09:42PM +0400, olive wrote:
olive> Yorick Cool wrote:
olive> >Er, no. There is an automatic warranty in sales, but you can contractually
olive> >dismiss it. And licensing software is not selling it. I do concede
olive> >that that to which you refer is a common (but erreoneous) perception.
olive> You can't contractually dismiss it in tne European Union. I have found
olive> for example the following reference:
olive> http://mineco.fgov.be/protection_consumer/councils/consumption/pdf_avis_2002/262.pdf
olive> It is well mention "obligation de garantie" (compulsory warranty). If
olive> you buy a CD at the local store; you have the two year warranty whatever
olive>  the "license" on the CD claim. It is probably the person who have sell
olive> you the CD who must provide the warranty; not the author of the

Beware, what you are citing is an opinion, and not the actual legal
framework. But more importantly, it deals with consumer protection (la
loi sur les pratiques du commerce du 14 juillet 1991 in Belgium),
which, for various reasons which I explore in my article, is not
applicable to software licenses. You are correct in your analysis of
the warranty of the CD, but only insofar as you are talking about a
warranty on the physical object, not on it's contents. Hence a vendor
has to warranty that the CD has no scratches and so on, but does not
warranty that the software on it is flawless. Again, I refer you to my

I'm sending it to you privately. If anyone else is interested, send me
a private mail (the article is in french).

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Reply to: