[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: Adding 'gwhois' to volatile



Martin Zobel-Helas wrote:
 + you change the package from a native package to a non-native package [1].
> [1] the package should be non-native anyway, so i don't mind if that
> changes.

Would you please explain why you believe the package should be non-native? I do not agree.

 + your DH_COMPAT level is 1 !!!!!!
 + if changing the DH_COMPAT to 4 the package doesn't build any more.

Yes. In the latest unstable version the build scripts were replaced with new versions. However as it is stated that the changes for a volatile package should be as minimal as possible, i left the build scripts for the volatile package as they are in the latest stable version. If you say it is ok to update the build scripts, i can do this.

 + you have all whois information in /etc and marked as conf-file. With
   any update of the package the enduser will be asked about changing
   the conf-file.

Untrue. If the user did not made any changes to the file (which would be true for the vast majority of users), no questions will be asked, but the file will be silently upgraded. But after all it _is_ a configfile and the correct place for it is in /etc.

gwhois is now nearly seven years old, and i know that some users depend on the configfile to be at that location. As i don't see any advantage of moving the file away from /etc, i hesitate to change this. A user can already make modification outside of this file by creating a file /etc/gwhois/pattern.xyz (xyz can be chosen freely) which takes precedence over /etc/gwhois/pattern, but some user depend on changing the main pattern file. It is a configfile and removing it from /etc would be against standards in my opinion.

Regard
Michael



Reply to: