Re: home videos to DVD
H. S. wrote:
I am planning to save all the MiniDV tapes (recorded with Sony TRV25
camcorder) on DVDs. I guess to capture the tape data to disk I can use
dvgrab or Cinelerra. And for editing and captioning I could use Kino.
But how do I record the video on to a DVD? Or if I just want to dump a
tape to a DVD, how do I just write all the video to DVD (without
captioning or editing)?
All inputs are welcome.
thanks,
->HS
+-----------------+
| DV-to-DVD-HOWTO |
+-----------------+
v1.0, 2004/01/05, Florin Andrei <florin@andrei.myip.org>
Here are some suggestions on how to convert Digital Video material (DV) to
DVD. This document is focused on material that's shot with DV camcorders. See
the end of the document for helper scripts.
1. About DV
Digital Video is a format used by most of the modern digital camcorders, both
in the proffesional arena and in the amateur range. The compression used is
kinda similar to MJPEG; each image is compressed independently of the others
(unlike MPEG1/2/4) so DV is "editing-friendly".
Usually, NTSC DV has a resolution of 720x480 and the pixels are non-square;
the aspect ratio is usually either 4:3 or 16:9; the framerate is 29.97 fps
and the image is interlaced, with the bottom field first. PAL is similar, but
the resolution is 720x576 and the framerate is 25 fps. Variations are
possible on non-standard and/or expensive equipment (24 fps, progressive,
etc.) but are rare.
At the normal parameters above, 60 minutes of movie get compressed by normal
DV gear at approx. 10...15 GB of video files.
2. About DVD
Very popular digital media, it's using MPEG2 encoding for video and a variety
of encodings for sound (MP2, AC3, DTS, PCM). There are several resolutions
permitted by the standard, 720x480 (NTSC) and 720x576 (PAL) being the most
popular.
The sum of the bitrates of the video track and of the current audio track
must not be higher than 10.08 Mbit/s, not even for a fraction of a second;
failure to comply generates DVDs that are unplayable on most standalone DVD
players. Usually, proffesional DVDs have their video tracks encoded at a peak
bitrate of 9800 kbps, hence leaving some room for an audio track. The average
video bitrate varies greatly, but it's usually between 2000...7000 kbps.
3. Capturing DV
You need a FireWire card and dvgrab version 1.4 or newer.
Run the "grab" script, then start the camcorder. "grab" is designed so that
it will create a new file for each new scene on the tape (a new scene begins
whenever you paused or stopped the camcorder when shooting). If the entire
tape was shot in one big scene, only one file will be created.
dvgrab can create OpenDML AVI files, so don't worry about file size, OpenDML
stuff can be as big as necessary.
At the end, stop the camcorder if it doesn't stop by itself, then CTRL-C the
script.
The order of the operations is important. Follow this document carefully.
4. Optional processing
You can preview the captured DV/AVI files with a media player. Currently,
Xine seems to be the only one supporting OpenDML.
If you don't want a scene, you can simply delete the corresponding file.
If you wanna make changes inside a scene, you must use a video editor that
understands DV and OpenDML; Kino seems to be working fine.
5. Transcoding to DVD
You need a recent transcode version, such as 0.6.11. You need a new
mjpegtools version as well, at least 1.6.1.92 (plain 1.6.1 won't work), or
1.6.2 when it will get released. You also need a fairly recent dvdauthor
version, such as 0.6.8.
The script that does the job is "conv-dvd". It is designed to work with a
capture project directory created by the "grab" script.
Let's discuss the script:
The $flags variable contains the parameters passed to mpeg2enc. You have to
choose one version and uncomment it; the first two are for high-quality
encoding, the last two are for efficient file size. Explanation of the
parameters:
-c means "all GOPs are closed"; this generates an MPEG2 stream that's more
compatible with various apps and players
-q sets the quantization factor; 6 is a reasonable value for DV material
converted to DVD; decrease it for higher quality, but be aware that you might
create video tracks that are not accepted by the multiplexer; increase it for
smaller file sizes at the expense of image quality
-4 2 -2 1 controls the motion estimation; an even better (quality-wise) value
would be "-4 1" but the quality increase is almost imperceptible while the
encoding speed decreases a lot; just leave it like it is
-K defines the encoder matrix; this script uses a matrix devised by Steven
Schultz to maximize the image quality, or the tmpgenc matrix for a more
efficient compression (at the expense of image quality)
-N is a very gentle low-pass filter that reduces the bitrate usage
tremenduosly while not affecting the image too much
-E tells the encoder to simply discard bits that are hard to encode yet do
not contribute to the image too much
-R controls the B frames; encoding with 0 B frames is unusual and some truly
broken players may get upset, although it is perfectly legal from the DVD
standard p.o.v.; encoding with 2 B frames is normal for proffesional DVDs but
it slows down encoding a lot (by 60%) and it makes the compression slightly
less efficient for amateur DV stuff (material that's less than _perfect_).
If you're like me and don't care about encoding speed (i let the script run
overnight), then encode with 2 B-frames; if you're in a rush or want to
obtain better compression (your space on the DVD is limited) then encode with
0 B-frames, but be aware of the broken players.
The $asr variable controls the aspect ratio. Uncomment the appropriate value,
depending on how your camcorder was configured. 4:3 is normal TV screen, 16:9
is HDTV. You cannot use one of them if your camcorder was configured with the
other.
The $bitr variable controls the MPEG2 bitrate used for the DVD.
WARNING: Do not increase it above 8500 regardless of what you've been told. I
know that proffesional DVDs are encoded at a peak value of 9800 kbps, i know
that various pieces of documentation recommend 9800 as One Value To Rule Them
All. Just ignore them. Trust me. If you do otherwise, sooner or later you'll
create a DVD that will not be playable on some standalone players. I learned
that the hard way. You have been warned.
Moreover, you don't truly need very high values. I did many evaluations, and
the results are pretty surprising: many scenes that i shot do not take the
peak bitrate above 7000 kbps, and the average is at 2000 or something! Only
very rarely you'll need such high bitrates.
Down below in the script you'll find the transcode command. Let's discuss
some command-line parameters:
-x ffmpeg tells transcode to use ffmpeg as the DV decoder instead of the
default Quasar codec. This way you'll obtain a compression better by 10% or
so.
--encode_fields b tells transcode that the DV material is "bottom field
first". For some reason, that's true for any DV camcorder in the world.
Commented out in the script you'll find some parameters for generating AC3
sound for your DVD instead of MP2. While AC3 is more popular, for some reason
there are audio/video sync issues if you use it. I'm still investigating the
bug, meanwhile MP2 should be perfectly fine, you can use it with no problems.
After transcoding, the script will multiplex the audio and video files using
mplex. The results are a bunch of VOB files. You can test each one of them
individually with a media player, since they're essentially MPEG2 files on
steroids.
After multiplexing everything, the VOBs are transformed in a DVD image on the
hard-drive with the help of dvdauthor.
The DVD is created so that each scene on the DV tape is translated into a
chapter on the DVD. I believe this makes a lot of sense and allows for a
simple way to jump to various scenes while playing the DVD.
This whole chapter affair is accomplished through the XML file that's built
while transcoding, which instructs dvdauthor to set chapter marks at the
beginning of each scene.
Of course, you can change all that, see dvdauthor documentation.
At the end, there are a few chown/chmod commands, to normalize file ownership
and permissions. I am not sure if this is really required, i just put them
there just in case. Remove them if they annoy you.
6. Test the DVD image
You can test the newly created DVD image with xine like this:
xine dvd:///full/path/to/the/dvd/image/
The trailing slash is important. xine will play the image just like it were a
true DVD, with chapters and all.
7. Burn the DVD
You need a fairly new version of dvd+rw-tools.
growisofs -speed=4 -Z /dev/scd0 -V "$label" -dvd-video $dvd-image
$label is the ISO label you desire. Usually, labels are all caps and do not
contain spaces. Example: MY_COOL_MOVIE
$dvd-image is the directory containing the DVD image.
Of course, you can change the speed and the DVD-Writer device to suit your
existing hardware.
+--------------------------+
| Appendix A - conf-dvd.sh |
+--------------------------+
----------------snip----------------
#!/bin/sh
if [ $# -ne "1" ]; then
echo "Usage: $0 dirname"
exit
fi
name=$1
pushd $name
# high quality, 80 min / DVD
# fast encoding, slightly unusual MPEG2 (no B frames)
flags="-c -q 6 -4 2 -2 1 -K file=matrix.txt -R 0"
# slower encoding, classic MPEG2
#flags="-c -q 6 -4 2 -2 1 -K file=matrix.txt -R 2"
#
# ok quality, 120 min / DVD
# fast encoding, slightly unusual MPEG2 (no B frames)
#flags="-c -q 6 -4 2 -2 1 -N 0.5 -E -10 -K tmpgenc -R 0"
# slower encoding, classic MPEG2
#flags="-c -q 6 -4 2 -2 1 -N 0.5 -E -10 -K tmpgenc -R 2"
# Aspect ratio of the original DV tape
# 4:3
asr="--export_asr 2"
# 16:9
#asr="--export_asr 3"
bitr="8500"
xmlf="dvdauthor.xml"
# Steven Schultz's combined HQ matrix
cat - > matrix.txt << MATRIX
# High resolution INTRA table
8,16,18,20,24,25,26,30
16,16,20,23,25,26,30,30
18,20,22,24,26,28,29,31
20,21,23,24,26,28,31,31
21,23,24,25,28,30,30,33
23,24,25,28,30,30,33,36
24,25,26,29,29,31,34,38
25,26,28,29,31,34,38,42
# TMPEGEnc NON-INTRA table
16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23
17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24
18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25
19,20,21,22,23,24,26,27
20,21,22,23,25,26,27,28
21,22,23,24,26,27,28,30
22,23,24,26,27,28,30,31
23,24,25,27,28,30,31,33
MATRIX
rm -f $xmlf
# dvdauthor XML config head
cat - >> $xmlf << XMLHEAD
<dvdauthor>
<vmgm />
<titleset>
<titles>
<pgc>
XMLHEAD
for inp in `ls dv`; do
out=`basename $inp .avi`
transcode -i dv/$inp -x ffmpeg \
-V -w $bitr \
--encode_fields b \
${asr} \
-F 8,"${flags}" \
-y mpeg2enc,mp2enc -b 224 -m $out \
-o $out \
--print_status 10
##################################################
# stuff to copy/paste in the transcode parameters
##################################################
# use this if DV sound is not sampled at 48kHz
# (it almost ALWAYS is 48kHz!)
# -E 48000,16,2 -J resample \
#
# AC3 sound
# (has A/V sync bugs, don't use it yet, still investigating...)
# -y mpeg2enc,raw -N 0x2000 -b 192 -m $out.ac3 \
#
# MP2 sound
# -y mpeg2enc,mp2enc -b 224 -m $out \
##################################################
# use this with MP2
mplex -r 10000 -f 8 -S 4400 $out.m2v $out.mpa -o $out.vob
# use this with AC3
#mplex -r 10000 -f 8 -S 4400 $out.m2v $out.ac3 -o $out.vob
echo "<vob file=\"$out.vob\" />" >> $xmlf
done
# dvdauthor XML config tail
cat - >> $xmlf << XMLTAIL
</pgc>
</titles>
</titleset>
</dvdauthor>
XMLTAIL
dvdauthor -o $name -x $xmlf
# the next commands require the following line in visudo:
# yourusername ALL = NOPASSWD: ALL
sudo chown -R root:root $name
sudo chmod -R 0755 $name
sudo chmod 0644 $name/*_TS/*
sync
popd
----------------snip----------------
+----------------------+
| Appendix B - grab.sh |
+----------------------+
----------------snip----------------
#!/bin/sh
if [ ! $1 ]; then
echo "Usage: $0 dirname"
exit
fi
name=$1
mkdir -v ${name} || exit
pushd ${name}
mkdir -v dv || exit
pushd dv
dvgrab --autosplit --size 0 --format dv2 --opendml \
--noavc --buffers 200 ${name}-
popd
popd
----------------snip----------------
I hope this helps
Bill K
Reply to: