Re: [PPP] Mulitple userids at one ISP
Jor-el writes:
> I think you will have seen Peter's proposed solution on
> debian-user to my problem.
Not yet.
> The trouble is that I cant figure out how it will work : nothing in ppp
> or the current Debian PPP setup seems to allow differentiation of the PPP
> daemon's behaviour depending upon the user that invoked 'pon'.
Use this script instead of pon:
/usr/sbin/pppd call $USER
and create a provider named after each user.
> 1. Setting up a different ISP for every user account at the ISP is
> simply hair-raising maintenance wise.
We're talking at cross-purposes a bit here, I think. I was assuming that
you already had the multiple accounts and were attempting to deal with
them. If your problem is multiple email addresses and a single ISP
account, look into fetchmail's multidrop capability.
> Then if I had another user genuinely dialing into a different ISP, or A
> himself having another account on another ISP, would complicate the
> issues. It would soon become impossible to keep track of the real ISP's
> and the 'fake' ones.
Nothing fake about any of them. Some just happen to be with the same ISP.
Some sort of a simple naming convention should keep them sorted out for
you.
> 2. What would prevent B from dialing into A's account by executing 'pon
> AC'?
The fact that you have put /etc/ppp/peers/AC in group 'A' and
/etc/ppp/peers/BC in group 'B'.
> If by saying '... number of ways (none using pppconfig)' you meant that
> the only solution is to hand-craft a PPP setup, then that is what I
> propose to change.
Perhaps you would like to revive the 'dunc' package? It did this sort of
stuff.
> The number one topic today that trips up newies is PPP configuration
> (video cards and X setups come a close second).
That doesn't seem to be the case with Debian.
> I think it is important that pppconfig is expanded in features to handle
> more cases.
pppconfig is intended for new users. I assume that system administrators
can handle the editing of a few rather simple config files. I try to
handle the most common cases first. As you are the first to bring up this
particular case, I must conclude that this is not a very common problem. I
will consider it, but I don't wnat to bloat pppconfig by trying to cover
every possible situation.
--
John Hasler This posting is in the public domain.
john@dhh.gt.org Do with it what you will.
Dancing Horse Hill Make money from it if you can; I don't mind.
Elmwood, Wisconsin Do not send email advertisements to this address.
Reply to: