Le mardi, 13 décembre 2016, 20.02:07 h CET Roger Shimizu a écrit : > I also found this page: > - > https://github.com/illwieckz/debian_copyist_brother/tree/master/material/ sources > > I didn't know there were so many packages from Brother .. Yeah. That's a big mess there. > However I think there may be more Japan local models with unique drivers. > I'll try to collect those drivers. > > BTW. What's the result of GSoC2015, other than the github repo above? > It'd be great if there's some progress .. I concluded the initial project with these comments: > * Brother makes it really complicated by bundling various files in > various licenses in literally hundreds of different packages with lots > of overlap and no publicly accessible source repository; > * In the middle of the project phase, Brother reworked their website and > broke the files reachability by hiding most behind a webform. > > Where I'm going to, is that I wonder if we could not have a wider > > packaging work around the Brother drivers: they come in vastly different > > forms, but bundle essentially a wide set of mostly-identical scripts. Many > > of these scripts assume they are installed in /opt and also assume 'lpd' > > is still the printer server in use. > > (…) > > That amounts to saying I don't think the package as packaged currently is > > really suitable for Debian main. > > Yes. So I guess it's better to remove my repo from alioth. Don't worry, it's fine. It's also good to have a first attempt there. > If supporting all Brother models is too difficult task, I think it'd > be better if we can get drivers of a few "popular" models into Debian > main (or non-free if main is not right place). Sure. It'd be good to start somewhere. But if that "somewhere" has an english website, it's also quite easier for me. :-) As you have probably seen from the git repository above, there are a lot of problems to solve: - Most if not all the cupswrapper* scripts do dangerous or stupid things: - including writing temporary printer filters - assuming everything is in /opt - need to run as root - force-create printers in CUPS - some of these are written in csh - etc - There is _a lot_ of duplication of code between these drivers. - There are stupid things spread around: > > - "Connecting more than one machine with the same model number is not > > supported" > > - "Some drivers are duplicated for SI unit (mm) or Imperial units (inch), > > see the TD-2020 for example." > > - "Many PPD are not distributed directly but embedded in Shell or C-Chell > > scripts from cupswrapper package, sometimes as heredocs, sometimes as a > > long list of echo commands." - Some drivers need the "LPR" driver, which is not available under a FLOSS licence. So far, the only way to drive any kind of sense out of all this was this approach: take all of what Brother makes available, put it in a giant repository, analyze what is free and what isn't, and drive conclusions from there. A possibility here is still to consider the problem too hard to fix, but it feels there is an opportunity for a global solution. If I had energy & time, I'd start with de-piling what this cupswrapper script does for the current package, and try to automatically extract the useful bits (filter script, PPD file), in the build-process, to provide these static assets as part of the binary package. I hope I haven't demoralized you too much here. :-/ -- Cheers, OdyX
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.