On Sat, Dec 27, 2003 at 11:24:41PM +0000, Henning Makholm wrote: > > The BTS is not a dumping ground for random wishlist request. > Dumping? Random? Yes. What's unclear about that statement? There are plenty of requests that *could* go into the BTS. For example, you could have a request that gcc not complain about legitimate C code like using gets() by default. Or you could have a request that the C library not implement functions that can't be used safely at all. Or you could have a request that exim4 not be the standard MTA. You can request all sorts of things that will never be implemented, quite sanely and reasonably. What isn't sane or reasonable is keeping irrelevant requests in the BTS as though they were somehow sacrosanct. > > Why leave it open? > To Not Hide Problems<tm>. That's nice. Unfortunately, missing misfeatures aren't a problem. > > Because wishlist requests in the BTS are the domain of the maintainer, > > not the user. > Why *should* it me the maintainer's domain to squelch deviant thought > in this way? Huh? Who's stopping Enrico or you from thinking "deviant" thoughts? Who's stopping you from posting them to -devel arguing for them? Who's stopping you from filing requests in the first place? On the other hand, it's certainly the maintainer's place to decide which features will and won't be implemented; in fact that's almost the entirety of the job description. And it's also the maintainer's place to ensure that the BTS listings for his/her packages are kept in order. I'm sorry you don't think I explained things well enough -- at the point where I'm told " do-foo yes" is crazy and stupid compared to " do-foo", and the person I'm talking to starts playing moronic games with control@b.d.o, I tend to think that further explanation would be a waste of time. Cheers, aj -- Anthony Towns <aj@humbug.org.au> <http://azure.humbug.org.au/~aj/> I don't speak for anyone save myself. GPG signed mail preferred. Linux.conf.au 2004 -- Because we can. http://conf.linux.org.au/ -- Jan 12-17, 2004
Attachment:
pgp_mFQGSgJSN.pgp
Description: PGP signature