[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: eicar.com installer in Debian, and pre-upload interface to ftpmaster



Marc Haber wrote:
> Because it makes debugging anti-virus software harder, and forces
> maintainers of anti-virus packages to have their own means of
> obtaining eicar.com for testing purposes
Debugging anti-virus software should be done by the maintainers thereof.
Why would a user need this?

> Saying a package is "silly" is a valid rejection reason in your
> opinion? Another reason is that a package depending on and
> recommending eicar-testfile would have to go into contrib. Yes, right,
> but there is Suggests: which allows a package suggesting
> eicar-testfile to stay in main.
Having an installer just because some organization is too lazy to provide a
license with a 68 bytes is plainly wrong (since eicar seems to be located in
Germany it might even be questionable whether they can claim copyright for
something of that size - but then they just could put it into the public domain).

> Well, _I_ find it impolite to say work that has been done by a
> volunteer is "silly". Actually, I find it discouraging to do any more
> future work for Debian
What did you want to package next? An installer that has a debconf prompt for
asking whether eicar.com, eicar.com.txt, eicar_com.zip, or eicarcom2.zip should
be downloaded?

Seriously, you're more substantial contributions have been accepted haven't
they? And that in spite of the fact that not having a legal name in deamon's
copyright file is questionable. And the package in question is just about the
silliest package I've ever seen (aside from those announced April 1st).


Cheers

T.

Attachment: pgpDVF74NuG4n.pgp
Description: PGP signature


Reply to: