Generally accepted cut-off limit for -doc packages
I volunteered to sponsor loki packages for Carleos Artime
<firstname.lastname@example.org>. The initial uploaded files are available
auric:/org/ftp.debian.org/incoming/REJECT> ll loki*
-rw-rw---- 1 troup debadmin 218108 May 1 16:03 loki-doc_2.4.6-1_all.deb
-rw-rw---- 1 troup debadmin 29765 May 1 16:03 loki_2.4.6-1.diff.gz
-rw-rw---- 1 troup debadmin 602 May 1 16:03 loki_2.4.6-1.dsc
-rw-rw---- 1 troup debadmin 1967 May 1 16:03 loki_2.4.6-1_i386.changes
-rw-rw---- 1 troup debadmin 359780 May 1 16:03 loki_2.4.6-1_i386.deb
-rw-r--r-- 1 troup debadmin 624 May 4 21:24 loki_2.4.6-1_i386.reason
-rw-rw---- 1 troup debadmin 871897 May 1 16:03 loki_2.4.6.orig.tar.gz
The reason file states:
The generally accepted cut-off limit for -doc packages is ~500k of
installed data; loki-doc isn't even half that. Please consider
merging the loki-doc package back into loki?
So I asked James Troup in private mail:
> Sorry I have not heared about such a "generally accepted cut-off limit for
> -doc packages". Ist it documented anywhere?
His answer was in the tense that I should clearly know and I should look
Sorry for my ignorance but I thought that there is a reference for his
rejection statement. I just made sure that the maintainer which I volunteered
to sponsor builded the package compliant to debian-policy 18.104.22.168 which says:
If a package comes with large amounts of documentation which many
users of the package will not require you should create a separate
binary package to contain it, so that it does not take up disk space
on the machines of users who do not need or want it installed.
I did not found a reference to a cut-off limit and would like to know which
additional document to debian-policy would define such a limit.
Any hints / opinions? If there is really a cut-off limit this should be
documented in developers-reference and a lintian check should make sure
that maintainers will be informed.