Gerfried Fuchs wrote: > * Jon Dowland <lists@alcopop.org> [2007-10-27 18:43:05 CEST]: >> I've removed the prboom.xpm icon that was added to prboom >> trunk. It is clearly derived from the cacodemon sprite in >> doom.wad / doom2.wad which are copyright ID Software, all >> rights reserved. I suppose a freedoom sprite could be used >> to derive an icon, not sure how good that would look. > > As this was yet another short sighted commit done by Kmos, can I > *please* get /any/ reaction on how the team plans to go on with such > cases? I've seen after the thread that I started yet another person > added - and I hope that there had been checks done on that person and > not the former habit of blindly accepting people just when they ask > continued. I totally agree with you. I set a personal goal to be really harsh releated to problematic changes for which a reply to my comments is not send in due time. I already have a pending revert (change made by bdfreese). > Especially, if the team wants to be liberal in adding people it should > also be liberal in removing them again - otherwise the team is pretty I also agree with this, too. > I haven't got any real reaction to the thread other than that Kmos > should be given the chance to speak up, though I haven't seen any > reaction, and I doubt that it will come any time soon, yet though I > have seen another commit from him changing the changelog of a package > removing a whole entry - which makes the package he uploaded to mentors > void. I really hope that noone is going to sponsor the tennix package Was this after the discussion about him? If so, I guess we could kick him out and if he feels he needs to be back, I guess he would have to reply to your/our concerns/questions. > I'm sorry, if this is the kind of quality and the sort of management > the games team is looking for I propably will have to pull wesnoth from no, at least *I* don't feel this is the level of quality we want. > the svn again, because this is not the kind of quality approach that I > can feel comfortable with or that I want to be associated with. Please, instad of running away from the problem, please, let's face it directly. You can count on my support on this. BTW, I have read a little about ACL implementation in SVN and it can be implemented, but is a little bit tricky. If anybody is interested to talka bout this/experiment, please contact me in private. If not, I will try to find some time for the experiments (but I fear that this is a technical solution to a social problem, as Rhonda suggested on IRC). > P.S.: There has been quite interesting discussions going on about him in > #ubuntu-motu where he managed to piss quite a lot of people off too > with his not thinking and especially not learning from mistakes > style. I was copied some of the more sever parts to some pastebin, > unfortunately they have expired, but <http://irclogs.ubuntu.com/> has > them all. That is interesting, sort of. Why not put it in your ~ on d.o or maybe team's http ~ on alioth? -- Regards, EddyP ============================================= "Imagination is more important than knowledge" A.Einstein
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature