[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: [AMENDMENT] Now is not the time to decide on firmware issue



I second the quoted proposal.

Frans Pop wrote:
> ============================ START OF AMENDMENT ==========================
> Considering that:
>    (1) The current discussion about what to do with sourceless firmware
>        is muddled by other discussions and time pressure because of the
>        release of Etch.
>    (2) The subject matter is extremely complex and most developers probably
>        do not have a clear understanding of what (sub)categories of files
>        are involved, what legal and practical issues are associated with
>        each of them, and what implications a decision on them will have for
>        e.g. the usability of the Debian installation system, nor what long
>        term implications a decision may have for the project as a whole.
> 
> The Debian Project:
>    (a) Affirms that the project strives for and encourages 100 percent
>        free software, including the availability of source for all types
>        of files.
>    (b) Resolves that the project needs more time before a decision can be
>        made on how sourceless firmware or other types of files (such as,
>        but not limited to, logos, images and video) are to be dealt with.
>    (c) Requests the DPL to delegate developers to prepare position papers on
>        the legal and practical issues surrounding these types of files in
>        view of both of the project's chief priorities: "free software" and
>        "our users".
>        These papers are to be presented to the project for discussion two
>        weeks before Debconf 7 and should include:
>        * a classification of the different types of files involved;
>        * a summary of legal issues with regard to the different types of
>          files;
>        * alternative technical solutions for dealing with different types
>          of files, e.g. in the archive and in the installation system;
>        * a statement about whether or not changes are needed/wanted in the
>          project's foundation documents in order to realize the proposed
>          solutions and possibly a proposal for these changes.
>    (d) Requests the DPL to facilitate the work of these teams by providing
>        access to legal counsel and other resources.
> ============================= END OF AMENDMENT ===========================


-- 
  ·''`.             If I can't dance to it, it's not my revolution
 : :' :                                            -- Emma Goldman
 `. `'           Proudly running Debian GNU/Linux (unstable)
   `-     www.amayita.com  www.malapecora.com  www.chicasduras.com

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature


Reply to: