[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: buster: low audio level



Jonas Smedegaard wrote on 2/12/20 1:26 PM:
> Quoting D. R. Evans (2020-02-12 19:05:40)
>> Jonas Smedegaard wrote on 2/12/20 10:43 AM:
>>> Quoting D. R. Evans (2020-02-12 18:34:27)
>>>> I just installed buster on a new (to me) machine, and the audio 
>>>> level is very low. With all the mixer controls and the physical 
>>>> volume control on the speakers turned up, I can hear audio, but 
>>>> even then it is unpleasantly quiet, certainly nothing one would 
>>>> want to listen to.
>>>>
>>>> Any suggestions as to how to fix this, or even how to go about 
>>>> investigating it sensibly, would be gratefully received.
>>>
>>> Maybe you missed some mixer controls?  Desktop environments nowadays 
>>> commonly use (not only ALSA but also) Pulseaudio, and a common 
>>> mistake is to only play with the knobs tied to ALSA.
>>>
>>> One relatively userfriendly interface to Pulseaudio that I know of 
>>> is pavucontrol, available in the Debian package of the same name.  
>>> You can run it as a self-contained graphical tool, or if you want it 
>>> handy accesible then additionally install pasystray.
>>>
>>
>> OK; I installed that, but it doesn't seem to do anything more than the 
>> desktop mixer program.
>>
>> It says that Analog Stereo Output is 100%, as does the mixer program. 
>> Moving that slider does make the volume even lower, so it is having an 
>> effect, but only to make the audio even harder to hear.
> 
> That sounds like you have looked at _one_ of the volume controls.
>> When I open pavucontrol (on my Debian unstable system, but should be
> similar e.g. on Debian buster), there are 5 tabs:
> 
>  * Playback
>    + one control per source (e.g. "System sounds", mpv, and microphone)

"System Sounds" is the only one. It's at 100%

>  * Recording
>    + one control per recorder (irrelevant for _playing_ audio)
>  * Output Devices
>    + one control per audio device (incl. virtual ones if enabled)

One slider, at 100%.

>  * Input Devices
>    + one control per audio device (irrelevant for _playing_ audio)
>  * Configuration
>    + switch to select routing mode (e.g. use HDMI instead of analog)

It's set to "Analog Stereo Output"; since my speakers are plugged into the
green jack at the back, it seems like that should be the correct selection.

> 
> Make sure that you check both application level volume (for the 
> application you want to test - while it is running) and output device 
> volume.  

At this point I've tried with several programs that I've used (on other
systems) for a long time. On all of them, even with the volume set to 100%,
the sound is audible but too quiet.

The same applications playing the same files on my debian 9 system produces
output that is too loud for comfort.

> Also, try available routing modes - they depend on your audio 
> device(s) so I cannot tell what is correct or optimal on your system.

I don't know what "routing modes" means, nor where to control them.

  Doc

-- 
Web:  http://enginehousebooks.com/drevans

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature


Reply to: