[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: HiDPI migration: desktop environment issue



On 25/12/17 01:44, Anders Andersson wrote:
If you can pull yourself from a Windows 95-era start menu and
always-visible panels, try the natural and more modern and updated
successor: Gnome 3. Really.

I found this "modern and updated" interface to have poor usability. It felt to me like an attempt to push the Android UI, optimised for tiny touch screens, on to the desktop.

I like always-visible panels on my desktop, including a pager, and Gnome 2 and XFCE give them to me, in multiple highly-configurable instances, with plugins. I found that Gnome 3 configuration was quite limited and required me to hack JavaScript at the system level. It has been a while since I tried a pure Gnome 3 and it might have improved.

I saw a Windows 10 machine a few days ago and it had an always-visible panel with something that seemed to work just like the like the start menu. Are Windows 10 desktops configured to have this by default? It might be that Microsoft are returning to the successful desktop interface design of previous generations. Perhaps Gnome 4 will as well?

I've never found the claims of Xfce being lightweight to hold up under
scrutiny. It's often more sluggish than Gnome 3 on the clients I've
compared.

Does Gnome 3 work over VNC yet? I had such problems with Unity, but XFCE just worked.

Kind regards,

--
Ben Caradoc-Davies <ben@transient.nz>
Director
Transient Software Limited <https://transient.nz/>
New Zealand


Reply to: