Re: lenny->squeeze upgrade - failed with grub-pc upgrade
On Mon, Aug 1, 2011 at 10:11 PM, Lukasz Szybalski <szybalski@gmail.com> wrote:
> On Sun, Jul 31, 2011 at 11:09 PM, Lukasz Szybalski <szybalski@gmail.com> wrote:
>> Hello,
>> In the process of upgrading from debian lenny amd64 to debian squeezy
>> amd64 I was able to successfully upgrade to kernel 32 and new udev.
>> Then after reboot I followed with apt-get dist-upgrade.
>>
>> Everything went fine, but towards the end I was asked to upgrade to
>> grub-pc. During this choice I was asked to specify mbr to install new
>> boot loader. I've selected my "flash" drive that I have used before to
>> hold my "boot" partition I believe.
>>
>> After restart I can only see "GRUB>".
>>
>> While Recovering from grub-pc install failure. I've started from cd
>> (rescue) mode. I then assembled my raid partition (sdb1,sdc1,sdd1) and
>> executed into shell of my lvm root group mapper_xyz_root. From there I
>> run "upgrade-from-grub-legecy" and this time I've selected my usb and
>> sda to install grub.
>>
>> Still no lock.
>>
>> Then I tried "update-grub"
>>
>> Now I get "grub loading...
>> no module name found"
>>
>> What should I do now? I've logged in with rescue cd again and now my
>> /boot partition no longer holds other files except for "/boot/grub/.."
>> What happened to my kernel files 26 and 32 that were on the /boot?
>>
>> What are my choices on installing grub-pc? Do I need "boot" partition?
>> What should be on it? Why did files got removed? Should I be
>> installing grub on my lvm root group? or sda? or /boot flashdrive?
>>
>> I would appreciate some guidance on this.
>
>
> LILO is not an option.
>
> I think the better question is where was the original grub installed
> (MBR?) and where is the new grub-pc (aka grub2 ) installed (mbr?)
> Will update-grub configure the whole system, or do I need to create my
> own config files? How do I install that to xyz sda mbr.
>
> Thanks,
> Lucas
>
"""
Lukasz Szybalski wrote:
> In the process of upgrading from debian lenny amd64 to debian squeezy
> amd64 I was able to successfully upgrade to kernel 32 and new udev.
> Then after reboot I followed with apt-get dist-upgrade.
You say "after reboot" and so you must have used grub to reboot,
right?
> Everything went fine, but towards the end I was asked to upgrade to
> grub-pc.
Asked to upgrade by asking you to run upgrade-from-grub-legacy
yourself manually from the command line? Or by some other means?
> During this choice I was asked to specify mbr to install new
> boot loader. I've selected my "flash" drive that I have used before to
> hold my "boot" partition I believe.
I think the most normal installation is to select your first raw
drive. That is, if you have /boot on /dev/sda1 and / on /dev/sda5 or
some such then you would install grub on /dev/sda without adding any
partition numbers.
**That is correct, I don't know why I thought I had a usb, but in this
computer I did not have a usb driver, so I should have selected
/dev/sda. In rescue mode I did that many times and it still failed.
> After restart I can only see "GRUB>".
Grub appears to be installed then. But the problem would seem to be
that grub's configuration file didn't point to the root filesystem.
** Correct, at that point I'm not sure if that was still grub 1 or
grub 2(grub-pc). (more on it below) The information below was very
useful after I gut the grub> menu.
At that point you can issue instructions to grub. You should be able
to get some good information. It is a little confusing to describe
but the most important thing to know is that TAB will expand and list
your possible options. Use this to explore your system at that point
and to see what is where. You can type in "help" to get a list of
commands available but that will produce a lot of output and will
overwhelm you.
At the grub prompt type in "root (" and then hit TAB to have it
complete. It will look like this:
grub> root (
Press TAB at that point and it will fill out to the available
options.
grub> root (hd0,
Press TAB again to have it list them out.
grub> root (hd0,
Possible partitions are:
Partition hd0,sda1
Partition hd0,sda2
Then select one of them and repeat to list the contents of that
filesystem.
grub> root (hd0,0)/
Possible files are:
lost+found/ System.map-2.6.32-5-686 vmlinuz-2.6.32-5-686 grub/
config-2.6.32-5-686 initrd.img-2.6.32-5-686
That verifies that on my system hd0,0 (/dev/sda1) is my /boot
partition. Repeat again with the other partition numbers.
grub> root (hd0,1)/
Possible files are:
bin/ boot/ dev/ home/ lib/ lost+found/ media/ mnt/ opt/ ...
That verifies that on the system I tried that hd0,1 (/dev/sda2) is the
root partition.
So to manually tell grub what it needs to boot I can type in the
following:
grub> root (hd0,0)
grub> kernel /vmlinuz-2.6.32-3-amd64 root=/dev/sda2 ro
grub> initrd /initrd.img-2.6.32-3-amd64
grub> boot
Use TAB to complete the filenames to ensure that you have the right
location and to save you from typing in all of the details of the
version numbers and architecture type.
If that works then your problem is not your grub install to the boot
partition but rather your configuration for grub in /boot/grub/* that
is the problem.
> While Recovering from grub-pc install failure. I've started from cd
> (rescue) mode.
A debian-installer disk in rescue mode should work okay.
> I then assembled my raid partition (sdb1,sdc1,sdd1) and
Why did you need to assemble the raid?
**I think in the "rescue CD mode it asks you to assemble raid or not"
You can select automatic assemble if you want to or you could pick a
different driver as your root. There was no issue with initrd as you
are suggesting below, but it made me pay attention to what is mounted
and what is not!!
That points to a different
problem. The raid should be automatically assembled by the initial
ram disk (initrd) and if it isn't then you are past grub and onto the
initrd phase of boot.
Did you by any chance add a disk to the raid but not rebuild the
initrd image? The initrd has the UUIDs of every disk in the raid as a
copy of the /etc/mdadm/mdadm.conf file in the initrd. If you have
added a disk to the raid and it is required for the lvm to start then
this also needs to be added to the initrd copy of the mdadm.conf
file. Otherwise it will fail to start the raid at boot time.
> executed into shell of my lvm root group mapper_xyz_root. From there I
> run "upgrade-from-grub-legecy" and this time I've selected my usb and
> sda to install grub.
I think you are mixing issues. I think you mixing up grub with raid
with lvm but really those are all separate. This is very easy to
become confused about but just the same I think that is what is
happening.
> Then I tried "update-grub"
>
> Now I get "grub loading...
> no module name found"
That I don't know.
** It seems as the because I am using 4 x 2TB drivers and all 4 were
created using GPT partition table, and my computer/mother board was
purchased before 2010 it does not support GPT EFI, so grub needed more
space then MBR allowed, and was telling me no module found because it
didn't have enough space to be installed.
Steps:
1. First I tried running the "grub-install /dev/sda" I would get:
grub-installer: grub-setup: warn: This GPT partition label has no BIOS
Boot Partition; embedding won’t be possible!
and
grub-installer: grub-setup: error: Embedding is not possible, but this
is required when the root device is on a RAID array or LVM volume.
I found this post:
<http://www.shuvoovuhs.com/linux/grub-installation-issue-with-2-tb-hdd-gpt-requires-bios-boot-partition/>
which said ( *have to* create a BIOS Boot Partition).
2. Reading up on it I concluded that my motherboard does not support
GPT EFI and therefore I do indeed need that partition:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BIOS_Boot_partition
3. Now since I only have one boot partition on /dev/sda1 (100mb) I had
199.9GB free. I decided to create a partition right after my 100mb. In
rescue mode cd I installed parted (in case its not installed)
aptitude install parted
then proceeded to install my new partition.
parted /dev/sda print
parted /dev/sda unit MB print
##this showed partion 1 as (31.4kb to 100MB)
parted /dev/sda
mkpart biosboot 100MB 101MB
##above created partition 2
set 2 bios_grub on
##Above enabled the bios grub partition
Then I did grub install and it successfully installed. (I rebooted and
it almost worked. I got the grub> ) but there was nothing there. I've
used what you email me to find my problem here.
When I did
grub-install /dev/sda
my /boot folder was in my "server1_lvmgroup-server1-root but that is
not what I had. My boot was a seperate disc /dev/sda1. So the proper
way I should have do it was:
ls /boot
#above shows only /boot/grub folder
umount /boot
#not mounted
mount -a
#this mounted my boot driver based on the /etc/fstab
ls /boot
#no I see
initrd.img-2.6.26-2-686
initrd.img-2.6.32-5-686
vmlinuz-2.6.26-2-686
vmlinuz-2.6.32-5-686
##Now I do install grub
grub-install /dev/sda
update-grub
##When you do update-grub it will find all kernels...it will say
found kernel 2.6.26...
found kernel 2.6.32....
reboot, and it worked.
I really appreciate your help.
This should really be in the Upgrades from Debian 5.0 (lenny), as if
your motherboard does not support GPT EFI then
upgrade-from-grub-legacy will fail, and there is no instructions on
how to go back.
I can't really say at what point during the upgrade I had grub>? but
it all came down to creating a GPT Bios boot partition for grub-pc
(grub2).
Thank you.
Lucas
***your email was most helpful. When I connected the dots with boot
partition then it all went smooth.
http://lucasmanual.com/mywiki/ will be back online shortly.
> What should I do now? I've logged in with rescue cd again and now my
> /boot partition no longer holds other files except for "/boot/grub/.."
> What happened to my kernel files 26 and 32 that were on the /boot?
Mounted the wrong partition? They should still be there. Take a deep
breath. Remain calm. Try it again. They should be there.
If you have somehow wiped them out then you will need to either
recover them or reinstall them from the chroot.
I have upgraded many machines from Lenny to Squeeze and although I
think this upgrade has the more problems of any of the previous
upgrades I have never had any of the problems you have mentioned.
> What are my choices on installing grub-pc? Do I need "boot" partition?
Yes.
> What should be on it?
Files such as:
System.map-2.6.26-2-686
System.map-2.6.32-5-686
config-2.6.26-2-686
config-2.6.32-5-686
grub/
initrd.img-2.6.26-2-686
initrd.img-2.6.32-5-686
vmlinuz-2.6.26-2-686
vmlinuz-2.6.32-5-686
> Why did files got removed?
Only you are in a position to know what you did.
> Should I be installing grub on my lvm root group? or sda? or /boot
> flashdrive?
Since you are getting the grub prompt then you have successfully
installed grub and your problem is with a later phase of the boot.
Bob
"""
Reply to: