Re: RFS: palp - Package for Analyzing Lattice Polytopes
Hi Julien,
On Wed, May 08, 2013 at 05:03:42PM +0200, Julien Puydt wrote:
> >debian/control:
> > I'd regard the description as quite weak. Any package management
> > tools are not capable to browse the internet and just relying to
> > two URLs to let the potential user understand what the program is
> > actually doing is not acceptable. Perhaps the focus on the pure
> > sagemath precondition is to strong here - each package itself should
> > feature a proper description to enable users (and also tools like
> > xapian indexer) find out easily what it is doing.
>
> I modified the long description.
OK
> >debian/copyright:
> > E-mail Address to Upstream-Contact would be nice if known.
>
> Added.
OK
> >debian/upstream:
> > For any scientific package I would expect some relevant publication.
> > Please confirm that you have checked that there is no such article
> > around or provide a proper debian/upstream file[3] (you can also use
> > the example for scientific references only here [4]).
>
> Added.
Great! I take this and your ack for the Blends issues I deleted from
this mail as "understood the Blends principle".
> >debian/changelog:
> > It has been turned out practical to use the target distribution
> > "UNRELEADED" (instead of unstable) as long as the package is not
> > yet uploaded.
>
> Modified.
... turned back to unstable and uploaded.
I also added an entry to
https://wiki.debian.org/DebianPureBlends/SoB
(even if I'm not sure whether there is really an RFS bug which I
personally do not request - just used the bug that is closed with
this upload.)
> Thanks for your remarks ; I hope things look better.
Yep! Thanks for all your work on this (not only after my nagging but
also for the other obviously quite good work to get the package
polished).
Kind regards and good luck with the whole sagemath effort
Andreas.
--
http://fam-tille.de
Reply to: