Bug#635994: foo2zjs makes use of embedded, patented libraries

[Ian Jackson <ijackson@chiark.greenend.org.uk>]

Arno Töll writes ("Bug#635994: foo2zjs makes use of embedded, patented libraries"):
> I was told by an anonymous user in #debian on OFTC (logs upon
> request available), that the foo2zjs package is making use of
> patentended code, embedded into its source. foo2zjs uses the jbigkit
> library [1] which in turn consists of paten- ted code [2].

Thanks for your interest.  You mean well, but it is better not to
discuss patent issues in public.

Please see this document:
  http://www.debian.org/reports/patent-faq

In particular:
  | How do I become aware of the existence of a patent?
  |
  | There are innumerable ways by which you may become aware of the
  | existence of a specific patent. Aside from being directly contacted by
  | a patent holder, you may learn about a particular patent through a web
  | search or mailing list, or in connection with your employment, etc. If
  | you do become aware of a patent that concerns you, it is best that you
  | speak to an attorney, rather than share such knowledge or speculation
  | in a public forum.

In this specific case, I agree with Macro d'Itri's posting.


Perhaps we should have a clear statement of procedure for people in
Arno Toll's position ?

Ian.