[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: RFS: wizznic



Hi Tony,

On Thu, 2011-08-04 at 15:58 -0500, Edgar Antonio Palma de la Cruz wrote:
> > Done.
> > - URL: http://mentors.debian.net/debian/pool/main/w/wizznic
> > - dget
> >   http://mentors.debian.net/debian/pool/main/w/wizznic/wizznic_0.9.2-preview2+dfsg-1.dsc

1.) Your get-orig-source target doesn't work with this version due to a
bug in debian/watch. Adding + to the allowed dfsg prefix chars fixes
this.

2.) The orig.tar.gz on mentors.d.n doesn't match the one generated with
get-orig-source. You had also removed:
Only in wizznic-0.9.2-preview2.orig//tools/releaser/data/win:
prgicon.png
Only in wizznic-0.9.2-preview2.orig//tools/releaser/data/win:
WizznicWin.bat
Only in wizznic-0.9.2-preview2.orig//tools/releaser/data/win:
WizznicWin-Fullscreen.bat
Only in wizznic-0.9.2-preview2.orig//tools/releaser/data/win:
WizznicWin-Zoom.bat

If that was done on purpose it should be added to the get-orig-source
target. IMHO they can be left as is.

3.) Your get-orig-source passes GZIP=--best but uses bzip2
compression. ;-)

4.) Having +dfsg as delimiter can be quite harmful. Usually ~dfsg is the
preferred method as this will always be lower than the upstream version.
Thus no matter what the next upstream version will look like, you can
bump your package up to that version.

5.) The multiline fields in debian/control need to have a whitespace as
first char not a tab stop to make them fully RFC822 compliant.

6.) Having libsdl-mixer1.2 additionally in Depends looks a bit strange.
Are you sure it does not come through shlibs?

7.) debian/README.debian-source doesn't need to be shipped with the
binary package. It's a comment on the source.

8.) debian/patches/makefile_media.patch wasn't pushed upstream AFAICT. I
guess upstream might be interested though.

9.) http://sf.net/wizznic/ is invalid. You probably mean
http://sf.net/projects/wizznic/

I've built using a freshly generated get-orig-source tarball, fixed 1.),
5.), 7.) and 9.) built, signed and uploaded your package.

You can find my upload at http://people.debian.org/~kilian/wizznic/

-- 
Best regards,
Kilian

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part


Reply to: