Re: bnetd and DMCA
On Thu, Feb 21, 2002 at 01:33:23PM +0100, Robert Millan wrote:
> If you check http://www.bnetd.org, you'll find
> a note explaining that their project has been
> branded as illegal by the DMCA.
s/DMCA/Blizzard/
> Bnetd is a server for networked playing with propietary
> Blizzard games like Starcraft or Diablo. It aims to provide
> the same features as the official BattleNet service.
>
> Those games are protected in a way that server addresses
> cannot be changed in order to use an unofficial server,
> but the bnetd project (and others, even blizzard itself
> used to) provides a tool to hack the game so that
> unofficial addresses can be used.
>
> What Blizzard claims is not well specified:
>
> "The aforementioned site either hosts or distributes software which
> illegally
> modifies and/or alters Blizzard Entertainment copyrighted software or
> bypasses anti-circumvention technology, thereby infringing upon Blizzard
> Entertainment copyrights."
*I* don't think that's a legitimate invocation of the DMCA. IANAL.
The whole argument is spurious anyway.
> The Debian package only contains the server code, which is
> written as free software from scratch.
>
> Is that package illegal?
No. Afaik, Debian has not received a cease-and-desist, and no court
has ruled that distributing bnetd is illegal.
If Blizzard sent us such a notice, we might pull the package rather
than argue the point...
> If it does indeed break the DMCA, would it be any problem
> in distributing it outside the US, where this law [1] does
> not prevail?
Not until the international versions come into force, no.
--
.''`. ** Debian GNU/Linux ** | Andrew Suffield
: :' : http://www.debian.org/ | Dept. of Computing,
`. `' | Imperial College,
`- -><- | London, UK
Reply to: