[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: [RFR] email-reminder debconf template



Quoting Francois Marier (francois@debian.org):
> (Please CC me on your replies)
> 
> Hello,
> 
> Please review the following template.  I have attached the current template
> file.


Here's my review. As, apparently, Justin did also a review, I'll send
both the diff and the new templates file. Up to you to take the best
out of our work..:-)

Rationale:

--- templates	2008-03-27 06:31:46.728757286 +0100
+++ templates.new	2008-03-27 06:36:58.016759369 +0100
@@ -1,33 +1,36 @@
 Template: email-reminder/send_reminders
 Type: boolean
 Default: true
-_Description: Send emails out?
- Email-reminder normally sends emails out every night.
+_Description: Send daily reminder emails?
+ Email-reminder is generally setup to send out daily email reminders.
+ .
+ Please choose whether you want to activate this feature.

Be more specific. These templates may come in the middle of the
installation of many packages.

The long description I propose keeps some kind of link with the
synopsis....but should be readable also *without* the synopsis. That
was the weakness of your version, imho.

So, I propose a wording which we generally propose in such situations.

 
 Template: email-reminder/smtp_server
 Type: string
 Default: localhost
 _Description: SMTP server:
- Enter the SMTP server to be used to send the emails out.
+ Please enter the outgoing mail server to use.

Usual wording for such prompts.
 
 Template: email-reminder/smtp_username
 Type: string
 Default:
 _Description: SMTP username:
- If your SMTP server needs a username, enter it here, otherwise
- leave this blank.
+ Please enter the username to use on the SMTP server.
+ .
+ Leave this blank if the SMTP server doesn't require authentication.

"username to use" is not the best....anyway.

This is not "my" SMTP server, I could be the junior admin on a big
corporate server..

Make it clearer why an SMTP server would require a username.
 
 Template: email-reminder/smtp_password
 Type: password
 Default:
 _Description: SMTP password:
- If your SMTP server needs a password, enter it here, otherwise
- leave this blank.
+ Please enter the password to use on the SMTP server.
+ .
+ Leave this blank if the SMTP server doesn't require authentication.

Parallel to the previous template....and sharing one string with it.
 
 Template: email-reminder/mail_from
 Type: string
 Default: root@localhost
-_Description: Sending email address:
- Emails will appear to come from this address.  Some SMTP servers
- require that this be a valid address.  Otherwise, the default
- value should be fine.
+_Description: Reminder mails originating address:
+ Please enter the email address to use as origin address in reminder
+ mails. Some SMTP servers require that this be a valid address.

I prefer saying that this address is the originating address for
reminder mails rather than a pretty vague "sending email address".

"The default should be fine" is a pleonasm. Default values should
always be fine..:-)

Don't use double spaces after dots. This is a controversial issue
among English native speakers but we try to suggest some
standardization on single spacing.


--- templates	2008-03-27 06:31:46.728757286 +0100
+++ templates.new	2008-03-27 06:36:58.016759369 +0100
@@ -1,33 +1,36 @@
 Template: email-reminder/send_reminders
 Type: boolean
 Default: true
-_Description: Send emails out?
- Email-reminder normally sends emails out every night.
+_Description: Send daily reminder emails?
+ Email-reminder is generally setup to send out daily email reminders.
+ .
+ Please choose whether you want to activate this feature.
 
 Template: email-reminder/smtp_server
 Type: string
 Default: localhost
 _Description: SMTP server:
- Enter the SMTP server to be used to send the emails out.
+ Please enter the outgoing mail server to use.
 
 Template: email-reminder/smtp_username
 Type: string
 Default:
 _Description: SMTP username:
- If your SMTP server needs a username, enter it here, otherwise
- leave this blank.
+ Please enter the username to use on the SMTP server.
+ .
+ Leave this blank if the SMTP server doesn't require authentication.
 
 Template: email-reminder/smtp_password
 Type: password
 Default:
 _Description: SMTP password:
- If your SMTP server needs a password, enter it here, otherwise
- leave this blank.
+ Please enter the password to use on the SMTP server.
+ .
+ Leave this blank if the SMTP server doesn't require authentication.
 
 Template: email-reminder/mail_from
 Type: string
 Default: root@localhost
-_Description: Sending email address:
- Emails will appear to come from this address.  Some SMTP servers
- require that this be a valid address.  Otherwise, the default
- value should be fine.
+_Description: Reminder mails originating address:
+ Please enter the email address to use as origin address in reminder
+ mails. Some SMTP servers require that this be a valid address.
Template: email-reminder/send_reminders
Type: boolean
Default: true
_Description: Send daily reminder emails?
 Email-reminder is generally setup to send out daily email reminders.
 .
 Please choose whether you want to activate this feature.

Template: email-reminder/smtp_server
Type: string
Default: localhost
_Description: SMTP server:
 Please enter the outgoing mail server to use.

Template: email-reminder/smtp_username
Type: string
Default:
_Description: SMTP username:
 Please enter the username to use on the SMTP server.
 .
 Leave this blank if the SMTP server doesn't require authentication.

Template: email-reminder/smtp_password
Type: password
Default:
_Description: SMTP password:
 Please enter the password to use on the SMTP server.
 .
 Leave this blank if the SMTP server doesn't require authentication.

Template: email-reminder/mail_from
Type: string
Default: root@localhost
_Description: Reminder mails originating address:
 Please enter the email address to use as origin address in reminder
 mails. Some SMTP servers require that this be a valid address.

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature


Reply to: