[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#782695: Bug#782404: release-notes: re-proofreading



Niels Thykier wrote in #782404:
> I just applied the patch in #782695 and I hope I can convince you to
> review it as well. :)

At a first glance I thought that patch only needed a couple of trivial
fixes - the spelling of "fulfil", some phrasing tweaks - but once I'd
taken it apart I couldn't get it to fit back together nicely.  I think
what I've ended up with is saying the same thing more clearly, but I
may be overdoing it, so I'd better CC Andreas.

Commentary:

 <section id="debian-med">
     <title>News from Debian Med Blend</title>
-    <para>The Debian Med team has increased the number of packages in the
-    field of biology and medicine again by a large amount.  However, not only

This isn't so much a "however" as a "moreover".

-    the number of packages was increased but also the quality of packages in

"Not only the FOO was BARred but also the BAZ" would be relatively
idiomatic; appending "was QUUXed" makes it hard to parse.

-    terms of testing (at package build time as well as autopkgtest) was
-    enhanced and supports the demand of Debian Med in a scientific

It's not clear if this is a demand by, for, or on Debian Med.  I think
it's saying that scientists are requesting results, and Debian Med is
supporting their demands - but that makes it sound like a petition.

-    environment to fullfill the request of scientists for reproducible
                       x   x
-    results.  These enhancements are reflected by version 2.0 of the Debian

The enhancements in the Blend are reflected by the Blend?

-    Med metapackages.  Feel free to visit the

I'm fairly sure I already was free to visit your web page!

-    <ulink url="http://blends.debian.org/med/tasks";>Debian Med tasks pages</ulink>
-    to see the full range of biological and medical software inside Debian.

s/inside/in/

My attempt:

+    <para>The Debian Med team has again considerably increased not only the number
+    of packages in the fields of biology and medicine but also their quality in
+    terms of testing (at package build time as well as autopkgtest). These
+    enhancements in version 2.0 of the Debian Med Blend metapackages reflect the
+    demand from scientists for reliable software to provide reproducible results.
+    Visit the <ulink url="http://blends.debian.org/med/tasks";>Debian Med tasks
+    pages</ulink> to see the full range of biological and medical software in
+    Debian.
     </para>
 </section>

-- 
JBR	with qualifications in linguistics, experience as a Debian
	sysadmin, and probably no clue about this particular package
Index: en/whats-new.dbk
===================================================================
--- en/whats-new.dbk	(revision 10775)
+++ en/whats-new.dbk	(working copy)
@@ -531,16 +531,14 @@
 </section>
 <section id="debian-med">
     <title>News from Debian Med Blend</title>
-    <para>The Debian Med team has increased the number of packages in the
-    field of biology and medicine again by a large amount.  However, not only
-    the number of packages was increased but also the quality of packages in
-    terms of testing (at package build time as well as autopkgtest) was
-    enhanced and supports the demand of Debian Med in a scientific
-    environment to fullfill the request of scientists for reproducible
-    results.  These enhancements are reflected by version 2.0 of the Debian
-    Med metapackages.  Feel free to visit the
-    <ulink url="http://blends.debian.org/med/tasks";>Debian Med tasks pages</ulink>
-    to see the full range of biological and medical software inside Debian.
+    <para>The Debian Med team has again considerably increased not only the number
+    of packages in the fields of biology and medicine but also their quality in
+    terms of testing (at package build time as well as autopkgtest). These
+    enhancements in version 2.0 of the Debian Med Blend metapackages reflect the
+    demand from scientists for reliable software to provide reproducible results.
+    Visit the <ulink url="http://blends.debian.org/med/tasks";>Debian Med tasks
+    pages</ulink> to see the full range of biological and medical software in
+    Debian.
     </para>
 </section>
 </section>

Reply to: