Le 06/01/2017 à 16:37, Ian Jackson a écrit : > Sebastian Andrzej Siewior writes ("Re: Feedback on 3.0 source format problems"): >> On 2017-01-03 16:58:21 [+0000], Ian Jackson wrote: >>> Looked at another way, it is trying to be a version control system, >>> layered on top of the Debian archive. But it is only about a quarter >>> of a VCS. There are no formal interfaces to do proper VCS operations. >>> If there is a formal interface, it is quilt(1) (which is itself very >>> poor. NB that is not quilt's fault: quilt inevitably has a hard job >>> because can't make enough assumptions). >> >> there quilt push, pop and header which seems enough. > > Well, it seems you don't really think so :-), because: > >> I usually have git-dpm which creates the quilt series and I try to >> keep patches documented. > > So you are using git operations to manipulate your patch stack. > git-dpm is one of the tools we have which lets you do that. Well, just to say, I'm personally quite happy with '3.0 (quilt)'. I try to maintain all my packages in git in unapplied state, because in my opinion this is the sensible thing to do. When I do a git diff upstream master I want to see only debian/ in there. I much prefer to check a diff of diff over a simple diff, because most of the time I want to see what changed in the packaging, not in the final state. When I want to do the later, I use debdiff. For me the patch is the final product, I like the clear separation between upstream and debian/, so it's for me a very appealing design to have individual patches in debian/patches. I use git to keep the history of the patch, not to manage it. I manage my patches using quilt. I would really prefer if sbuild et al. would revert the patches after building by default, but that's life. I respect that other people have other views. I'm not interested at the moment in dgit or other wrappers because 1- they seem to me to add complexity to the process; 2- I prefer to understand what I'm doing. Kind regards, Thibaut. -- * Dr Thibaut Paumard | LESIA/CNRS - Table équatoriale (bât. 5) * * Tel: +33 1 45 07 78 60 | Observatoire de Paris - Section de Meudon * * Fax: +33 1 45 07 79 17 | 5, Place Jules Janssen * * thibaut.paumard@obspm.fr | 92195 MEUDON CEDEX (France) *
Attachment:
smime.p7s
Description: Signature cryptographique S/MIME