[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: MBF alert: packages with very long source / .deb filenames



On Sat, 26 Mar 2011 14:32:27 +0000, Ben Hutchings wrote:

> > > I think so. The package with long names tend to follow a naming policy
> > > that sort of imposes the long name... so if we put a too-short limit
> > > then we're asking them to make an exception in the naming policy.
> > Right, that's certainly true for the lib.*-perl packages, and I
> > wouldn't know how we should rename them in a sane way.
> The really absurdly long names Steve found seem to be used for secondary
> source tarballs for some v3 source packages, where the file name
> essentially includes two full Perl module names.  

Thanks for the pointer, I admit that I have missed this detail.

For the two packages listed in Steve's mail that gives us:

libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5-1.debian.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5-1.dsc
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig-CGI-Application-Dispatch-2-17.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig-CGI-Application-Plugin-AutoRunmode-0-17.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig-CGI-Application-Plugin-ConfigAuto-1-32.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig-CGI-Application-Plugin-DBH-4-00.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig-CGI-Application-Plugin-DebugScreen-0-06.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig-CGI-Application-Plugin-DevPopup-1-06.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig-CGI-Application-Plugin-ErrorPage-1-21.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig-CGI-Application-Plugin-FillInForm-1-15.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig-CGI-Application-Plugin-Forward-1-06.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig-CGI-Application-Plugin-LogDispatch-1-02.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig-CGI-Application-Plugin-Redirect-1-00.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig-CGI-Application-Plugin-Session-1-03.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig-CGI-Application-Plugin-Stream-2-10.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig-CGI-Application-Plugin-ValidateRM-2-3.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig-CGI-Application-Plugin-ViewCode-1-02.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig-CGI-Application-Standard-Config-1-01.tar.gz
libcgi-application-basic-plugin-bundle-perl_0.5.orig.tar.gz

libcgi-application-plugin-authorization-perl_0.07-1.debian.tar.gz
libcgi-application-plugin-authorization-perl_0.07-1.dsc
libcgi-application-plugin-authorization-perl_0.07.orig-driver-activedirectory.tar.gz
libcgi-application-plugin-authorization-perl_0.07.orig.tar.gz

> If that's specified in
> current Perl policy, it should be fixed (and can be fixed without
> confusing users).

AFAIK the submodule names were just made up and can be shortened (in
fact, for the second package it's already a "made-up" name).

(Not that this gives us much room -- in the second case we're already
down to 84 characters ...)


Cheers,
gregor
 
-- 
 .''`.   http://info.comodo.priv.at/ -- GPG key IDs: 0x8649AA06, 0x00F3CFE4
 : :' :  Debian GNU/Linux user, admin, & developer - http://www.debian.org/
 `. `'   Member of VIBE!AT & SPI, fellow of Free Software Foundation Europe
   `-    NP: Dire Straits: Brothers In Arms

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature


Reply to: