[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: Bug#265762: ITP: tpop3d -- tpop3d is a fast, extensible, secure UNIX POP3 server

Thomas Viehmann wrote:

Well, choice is about having multiple packages offering distinct
benefits. Choice is not about having two dozen half- to un-maintained
packages failing to achieve the same goal. Being offered 20 packages
isn't exactly a service to the user if he cannot be certain how long and
how well the packages will be cared for. [1]

I cannot see how politely asking prospective packagers to describe the
value they think their particular package adds to the archive is
There's >50 orphaned packages (where the ex-maintainer or someone else
cared enough to do an upload assigning the package to qa) that have not
been in woody, and probably quite a few ones that have been uploaded and
are ill-maintained (why are 200 packages with RC bugs not in sarge?), so
it's only reasonable to try to estimate the likelihood that a new
package will share the same fate. Being the 10th daemon for a given
service might not decrease that.

Kind regards


Hi Thomas at all,

I already found big (?) bug with Debian all versions probably, but not sure how to fill bugreport correctly ;) I will try to describe it. Maybe someone will help me clearing situation. Once after reading DWN, I wanted to contribute to my favorite distro. I packed tpop3d. And we have question of the day: "why? There are lots of bugs to fix in existing packages". Ok, I said. And started to look at wnpp lists. Ok, found one small package: wmnetmon. Just for beginners. Right for my work, but I'm using different ;). As described in NM guide, I asked for current maintainter to take over his maitenance. He welcomed my idea. Then I fixed some bugs, added new translation (not so big) and anounced it on debian-mentors list asking for sponsorship (old maintainer has no time for it). Thanks for Andreas Metzler and Wesley J Landaker for reviewing package and helping me to correct mistakes. But what is interesting in all this - nobody answered with "yes, I will sponsor you". Of course, it is only four days past my request, but who can guarantee that answer will be? Now I see my bug. On next bugfix in orphaned package I should ask - will be there sponsor. And I think every beginner should ask this question before doing something. Because after spending half of sunday learning new features it is pitty to find that nobody needs your work. This is big bug from my point of view.

Sorry for such long letter,

Reply to: