[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#764587: installation-reports: After successful installation from usb stick the stick is not recognised on reboot.



On Tue, Nov 25, 2014 at 03:40:06PM +0000, Steve McIntyre wrote:
> Apt guys, how much effort would it be to add an extra package source
> (derived from cdrom), called apt-usb or similar?

The apt-cdrom code is practically unmaintained, so if anyone is really
interested in any improvements in that area: Now (modulo jessie, so
maybe in a few weeks instead) would be a good time to get active…


That said: Where available apt-cdrom is using udev to figure out
mountpoints. Currently, it is looking for CDROMs only, but setting
APT::cdrom::CdromOnly to false should tell it to look for any
mountpoints which are "removable" instead.

I further see some code using ".disk/" with a comment starting with
"if we are on a writable medium (like a usb-stick)" so I presume this
could already work, but I have never tried.¹

This says nothing about systems where udev isn't available (for various
reasons) of course and as said, it is practically unmaintained, so at
least I am not flipping any default value in code I only touch for one
reason: d-i breaks because I have changed something """unrelated""".


The best approach might be to move apt-cdrom to apt-transport-cdrom (it
is currently a bit entangled with other code, but removing this is not
the worst idea anyhow) and finding maintainer(s) for it. These can
probably come up with a way better name than "cdrom" as well. All I can
come up with is "removable" which has a slightly different meaning for
me if its attached to code. ;)

(As usual, if you are said volunteer feel free to contact me (or better
yet deity@) and we will do what we can to help you out; I just want to
make cristal clear that we don't have the resources to do it ourselves).


Best regards

David Kalnischkies

¹ well, we have a testcase which works with cdrom sources which
obviously doesn't need to burn and mount a test cd, so I am pretty sure
that the using part works. I am just not too sure about udev, mounting,
multidisks, interaction with d-i (and others) and similar "details"…

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature


Reply to: