Hi, Thue Janus Kristensen: > I don't know enough about Michael Ossipoff's suggested complete > change of voting system to have an opinion about that. > It's not a "complete change". The basic Condorcet method is unchanged. We merely change (fix?) what we do when there's no single winner. I have to admit that I think that the rationale behind the Beatpath method which we use to clean up a nontrivial Schwartz set is somewhat obscure. If using IRV instead fixes a problem that shows up in real-world elections with few voters, particularly when the vote is not secret, then I'm in favor of replacing it. > But I think > that if Debian stays with the current Condorcet method, then my > (and Michael Ossipoff's I guess) suggestion of moving §A.6.3 down > as the last step is a simple and obvious must-have fix. > Agreed. -- -- Matthias Urlichs
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: Digital signature