Re: Proposal: Source code is important for all works in Debian, and required for programmatic ones
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
I second this proposal.
Don Armstrong <email@example.com> writes:
> Because there appears to be some residual confusion about
> what I actually proposed and its content, here is the proposal as it
> currently stands. The proposal is only the content between BEGIN
> PROPOSAL and END PROPOSAL.
> ========== BEGIN PROPOSAL =====================================
> The Free Software movement is about enabling users to modify the works
> that they use on their computer; about giving users the same
> information that copyright holders and upstream developers have. As
> such, a critical part of the Free Software movement is the
> availability of source (that is, the form of the work that a copyright
> holder or developer would use to actually modify the work) to users.
> This makes sure that users are not held hostage by the whims (or lack
> of interest or financial incentive) of upstreams and copyright
> Different types of works have different forms of source. For some
> works, the preferred form for modification may not actually be
> digitally transferable. For others, the form that originally was
> preferred may have been destroyed at some point in time, and is no
> longer available to anyone. However, to the greatest extent
> possible, the availability of source code to users is a critical
> aspect of having the freedom to modify the software that is running
> upon ones computer.
> Recognizing this, the Debian Project:
> A. Reaffirms that programmatic works distributed in the Debian
> system (IE, in main) must be 100% Free Software, regardless of
> whether the work is designed to run on the CPU, a subsidiary
> processing unit, or by some other form of execution. That is,
> works must include the form that the copyright holder or upstream
> developer would actually use for modification.
> B. Strongly recommends that all non-programmatic works distribute
> the form that the copyright holder or upstream developer would
> actually use for modification. Such forms need not be distributed
> in the orig.tar.gz (unless required by license) but should be
> made available on upstream websites and/or using Debian project
> C. Reaffirms its continued support of users whose hardware (or
> software) requires works which are not freely licensed or whose
> source is not available by making such works available in
> non-free and providing project resources to the extent that
> Debian is capable of doing so.
> D. Requests that vendors of hardware, even those whose firmware is
> not loaded by the operating system, provide the prefered form for
> modification so that purchasers of their hardware can
> exercise their freedom to modify the functioning of their
> 1: Consider film negatives, or magnetic tape in the case of audio
> 2: Here it must be emphasized that we refer to "technically possible"
> or "possible for some party" as opposed to "legally possible for
> Debian". We also assume digital distribution, and do not attempt to
> require the distribution of physical objects.
> ============= END PROPOSAL ===============================
> If necessary, consider this an amendment under A.1.2; seconders, you
> may object to the "changes" under A.1.5. (If you decide to re-second
> this proposal, please only second the part between the === lines.)
> I've also attached the suggested content for the v.d.o webpages for
> this option in the interest of completeness.
> Don Armstrong
> 1: http://cvs.debian.org/webwml/english/vote/2006/vote_004.wml?root=webwml&r1=1.3&r2=1.4
> 2: http://lists.debian.org/debian-vote/2006/09/msg00228.html
> 3: http://lists.debian.org/debian-vote/2006/09/msg00235.html
> CNN/Reuters: News reports have filtered out early this morning that US
> forces have swooped on an Iraqi Primary School and detained 6th Grade
> teacher Mohammed Al-Hazar. Sources indicate that, when arrested,
> Al-Hazar was in possession of a ruler, a protractor, a set square and
> a calculator. US President George W Bush argued that this was clear
> and overwhelming evidence that Iraq indeed possessed weapons of maths
> http://www.donarmstrong.com http://rzlab.ucr.edu
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.5 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: Processed by Mailcrypt 3.5.8+ <http://mailcrypt.sourceforge.net/>
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----