[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: no x windows

yes, thanks. that did the trick nicely.

i did an:
apt-cache show openssh-server | grep Depends | sed -e 's/,/\n'
which of course didn't show the 'Recommends' so i totally missed looking for that.

though, i don't think i'll forget this one again any time soon :)

On Sun, Dec 5, 2010 at 12:55 AM, Phil Requirements <simultaneous@comcast.net> wrote:
On 2010-12-04 23:07:31 -0500, shawn wilson wrote:
> so, i go to install openssh-server on a machine that i intend to be a web
> development environment and it wants to install libx11-6, x11-common,
> libx11-data and some other stuff. i went to track down what was depending on
> x libraries, but i decided it really doesn't matter - why do i need x
> libraries to run an ssh server?

You certainly don't need X to have a ssh server. I only looked at it
it briefly, but I'm guessing it tried to install the package "xauth",
which is a "recommends" of openssh-server.

The new default for aptitude is to say "yes" to recommends. There is a
way to configure your machine so that it says "no" by default to
recommends. That has been discussed recently on this list.

> i've spent two hours googling (and even bing) on how to keep x windows off
> of debian. i've found tons of stuff about x windows problems which is ironic
> since my problem is keeping a minimalistic system which doesn't include x. i
> know one of the options gentoo's ports offers is not installing x (or used
> to offer).

I can see that you would have trouble find that information in a web
search.  I think that getting a system with X should be as simple as
not allowing it to be installed. I think the problem you are running
into is that the package system is pulling in recommends

> i've found some options in dpkg, but nothing in apt-get. i don't see anyway
> to pass dpkg's --ignore-depends with apt-get. i'm thinking i'm looking for
> something in /etc/apt/apt.conf or apt-config but i can't come up with
> anything.

You can ignore a recommends at the time of installing by doing:

   aptitude install openssh-server -R

I don't use apt-get, but when I search inside the man page...

   man apt-get

...I see the option "--no-install-recommends". So that would translate

   apt-get install openssh-server --no-install-recommends

If you want to set an option so that aptitude says "no" by default
to recommends, you can try this tutorial:


> is it possible to have a functioning debian install without x windows? if
> so, why isn't this documented maybe in the debian faq or something?

Yes, many computers do not use X, especially server computers.

I think one reason it is not documented is because many people setting
up CLI-only computers, or server computers, are already experienced
with wrangling their package management software.

Hope this helps,


To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-user-REQUEST@lists.debian.org
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmaster@lists.debian.org
Archive: [🔎] 20101205055557.GA18754@kasploosh.net" target="_blank">http://lists.debian.org/[🔎] 20101205055557.GA18754@kasploosh.net

Reply to: