[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: OT: SecurDisc Technology on DVD Drives



Disclaimer: my comments are based on 15 minutes of searching the web,
I'm not familiar with securdisc at all.

On 2008-09-01 21:29 +0200, KS wrote:

> I am looking to purchase an internal DVD writer (SATA) and have noticed
> that some of these drives come with what they call SecurDisc technology.
> Their website www.securdisc.net says that it "protects" your data from
> unauthorized copying and even allows you to recover data from damaged discs.

At least the latter isn't exactly new, there is free software that does
the same thing (dvdisaster).

> What I understand from their website is that one needs Nero 7 or 8 for
> that technology to work. I was wondering if (and how) their technology
> can affect a Linux user. I rather not choose the drive with that feature
> if it hinders anything in Linux. Does anyone know about this technology?

If you use the securdisc feature, the discs will not be readable under
non-Windows operating systems.  It is probably not dangerous to use such
a drive as long as you don't use Nero for burning your data.  But I
suppose that these drives will come with an OEM version of Nero (what is
their "extra value" without one?), and I'd rather choose not to pay a
single cent for useless proprietary customer-lock-in software.  That's
up to you, though.

Sven


Reply to: