Re: top post fixer?
John C <zcar@satx.rr.com> wrote: Steve Lamb wrote:
> John C wrote:
>> It's kinda like a religious fanaticism... "everyone should act and
>> believe like I do". And yes, you're absolutely right - there is too much
>> bile being spewed at top posters.
>
> No, it's not. It's called a convention for communicating with one
> another. Do you call it religious fanaticism that everyone is taught the
> language of the location they were born? I certainly don't, I called it an
> education. Simply put top-posting marks the poster as uneducated in how to
> communicate online, period.
Wow! and you don't think that's fanaticism?? :-)
I'll just cut out the "so-called" facts over which you and I will never agree. (I've heard them all before-thank you) Let's just say that I
never use a computer in a pitch black room, it's always well lighted.
The point of this discussion is that users are being turned off by the insistence that they should only post in the manner that the "educated" think they should - "bottom posting only please."
There are valid reason to correct posters that use html, long lines, attachments, etc. All are violations of the code of conduct for the Debian mailing lists - Top posting is not.
Correcting someone who happens to top-post on this list is nothing other than imposing the personal preference of the individual doing the correcting.
If it's the will of all of us, put in the the code of conduct. Until then let's just drop the subject and quit correcting users, it's getting dangerously close to the definition of a flame war :-)
Kind of related.
My apologies to Francis and Paul for accidentally "CC"ing them on
my earlier posting - that *is* a violation of
the code of conduct.
John
That's OK by me John. I just want to get back to hearing about Debian. I use computers and Debian as part of my job, but I also use Debian sysems as my hobby. I mostly read the lists to pick up usefull information, and I'm glad when I see something I know how to solve. And I dont get the insistence on bottom posting. When I am checking my e-mail (lots of e-mail by the way) I want to see the current reply and don't mind scrolling down if I need to read the original post. I also at times (most of the time) use a crappy webmail interface that does some of the "bad" stuff by default.
Reply to: