Re: Source ISOs
On Fri, Jul 30, 2004 at 04:01:35PM +0800, John Summerfield wrote:
> Sven Hoexter wrote:
> >On Thu, Jul 29, 2004 at 04:10:06PM +0200, Lucio Crusca wrote:
> >>Hello everybody.
> >>I'm a Debian CD vendor and a customer asked me the source distribution
> >>(woody). However I and my customer both don't know how one can install
> >>those CDs, and I'd like to know what exactly a source distribution is
> >>before selling one.
> >Source CDs contain the source packages of the binary packages distributed
> Where exactly are they?
Aehm depends on what's on your binary CDs ... the source packages for the
offical Debian packages can be found on a mirror close to you.
Iso images with the source packages for woody should be avaible in the same
place you can grab the binary image.
> >the binary CDs. In short it's the source code of the software. I advice you
> >to read through the GPL and other licences cause some force you to
> >the source code along with the binary stuff. Ah and talking about the GPL
> I'm not sure that's quite true.The GPL for one, requires you to provide
> source _on request._ I don't think it requires anyone to provide source
> to someone they did not provide binaries though,
Ok as I read it it's an or. You've the choice between a written offer (3b)
or simply include them anyway (3a)
> >afaik you've to archiv the source code for the stuff you distribute in
> >for 5 years.
> I'm not sure that's true either, though I if it is I'd appreciate the
> pointer. I think it's acceptable to give the client the choice at the
> time of purchase of the original binaries.
Well it's only for 3 years and not for 5 years. Sorry my fault.
> There are reasons which may be beyond one's control that one cannot
> offer the source code at some time on the future.
Well you should take care to not get in such a situation. I mastered the
Debian/woody image for the LinuxTag 2003 and we made 3 copys of the source
CDs and gave them to 3 different people so that there is a good chance that
everything is still avaible in 3 years.
Anyway this is a problem for lawyers. I just wanted to point out that there
are clauses about this topic in the GPL.
It ain't so bad bein' alone if you know it'll never last nothing lasts forever
'cept the certainly of change and love's the same It's a game with simple rules
If you think it's forever then you're nothing but a fool
[Venerea - Love Is A Battlefield Of Wounded Hearts]