[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: Bounced Message but still sent to list *partly solved, not on my side*



> The mail bounced because it was attempted to be delivered to
> debian_user@green.hartshorne.net.  However, the server handling the
> domain green.hartshorne.net can't find a user named "debian_user".
> 
> This is only half of the story, though.  The mail server for
> green.hartshorne.net is horridly broken.  There are two locations in
> an email for the sender and two for the recipient(s).  One location,
> which you are familiar with, is the message headers.  The other is the
> envelope.  Just like snail-mail, the message has contents (headers and
> body) and an envelope.  Snail-mail works like this :
>     1) The postoffice reads the envelope to determine where to deliver it.
>     2) If delivery can't succeed, the postoffice reads the envelope to
>         see where to return the package with notification of the
>         problem.
> Email is works the same way.  However, some systems decide that the
> envelope isn't good enough.  They rip open and read mail that isn't
> theirs, and then decide to deliver the bounce to the sender mentioned
> in the headers, not the one on the envelope.
> 
> The rest of the story is this :  somehow, at some time, the address
> debian_user@green.hartshorne.net was subscribed to the list.  Later
> that user no longer exists at that domain.  Now you send a message to
> the list, and the list dutifully passes it on to all subscribees.  One
> thing the list manager does is change the envelope sender so that
> bounces will automatically be handled by it.  Instead, that broken
> mail server sent the bounce to you since your address is in the "From:"
> header.

Ah, ok.. so I guess that means it's not a fault on my side. *wipes away
sweat from forehead* I hate that.

Why don't the list maintainers wipe the faulty address?

-- 
Michelle Alexia "Jade" Storm
Dragon Impersonating a Human and failing.

Attachment: pgpCzo7nwGL5W.pgp
Description: PGP signature


Reply to: