On Mon, Apr 20, 1998 at 05:46:10PM -0700, George Bonser wrote: > I quote from the copyright: > > ... > > Permission to use, copy, modify, and distribute this software and its > documentation for any purpose and without fee to the University of > Washington is hereby granted, provided that these legal notices appear in > all copies and supporting documentation, that the name "Pine" is retained, > and that the name of the University of Washington is not used in > advertising or publicity pertaining to distribution of the software > without specific, written prior permission. This software is made > available "as is". > > Although the above trademark and copyright restrictions do not convey the > right to redistribute derivative works, the University of Washington > encourages unrestricted distribution of patch files which can be applied > to the University of Washington Pine distribution. > > ... > > Someone in Debian saw that second paragraph and thought "gee, we make a > patch file to create our package so we must have a derivative work". > We have to distribute the debianization as a separate file in source form > only. > > I think that is incorrect and I further suspect that nobody contacted > washington.edu to make sure. I will bet that what debian does is ok > since we are doing only what the end user has to do anyhow. It is simply > a matter of someone taking an interpretation to an extreme. Nowhere does > it say in that copyright that you can not distribute a binary. That is > all that debian is doing. I do believe the above paragraph does indicate that only pristine binary and source packages may be distributed. The source packaging seems okay though. What I would suggest be done is to create a package which includes the source, dsc file, etc in /usr/src/pine-src as was done for qmail. Add a quick README.Debian to the thing telling person who has just installed this source package how to build it. You could even give them this script: #!/bin/sh dpkg-source -x pine_3.96L-7.dsc cd pine-3.96L dpkg-buildpackage -B -uc cd .. There, that's it. 4 lines and 3 .deb files later. Then just install the ones you want and call it good. I don't see the problem here.
Attachment:
pgpRXCYUTjaBU.pgp
Description: PGP signature