Am 29.04.19 um 21:53 schrieb Niels Thykier: > wferi@niif.hu: >> On Wed, 27 Mar 2019 20:12:00 +0000 Niels Thykier <niels@thykier.net> wrote: >> >>> Related note (with my RT hat on): Please defer debhelper compat bumps >>> for anything targeting buster as it is not considered a "minimal change". >> >> Dear Release Team, >> >> I recently realised that #887904 (dh_installsystemd will unmask services >> *after* an attempt to start them) affects pacemaker (and probably every >> other debhelper compat level 11 daemons with a native systemd unit). >> The symptom: >> >> apt install pacemeker => pacemaker is running, good; >> apt remove pacemaker => pacemaker is not running, good; >> apt install pacemaker => pacemaker is still not running, NOT good; >> service pacemaker start => pacemaker is running, good. >> >> I think this is a bug, although probably not a policy violation. What >> should one do for buster? >> 1. Don't care, >> 2. try to fix this somehow on compat level 11 (how?), I wanted to see, how many packages are potentially affected. The criteria I used was: - the package needs to ship a systemd.service file and SysV init script with a matching name - debian/compat contains 11 or debian/control the string "debhelper-compat (= 11)" The resulting list shows 185 potentially affected source packages, which is unfortunately quite a lot (attached as list.txt) > Another package had a similar issue and here I recommended the use of > DH_COMPAT (and override targets) to selectively bump the compat level of > dh_installinit and dh_installsystemd to compat 12. > > E.g. > > override_dh_installinit: > DH_COMPAT=12 dh_installinit ... > > override_dh_installsystemd: > DH_COMPAT=12 dh_installsystemd ... > > Note the exact runes needed depend on your existing compat level and > package; the above runes are geared towards compat 11 but are untested. > For compat 10 and earlier you want a similar but slightly different > approach. > > I believe that is the (general) route/path of "least evil/problematic" > for buster (without having looked at the concrete packaging at all). I picked a package from list.txt at random: uptimed I verified that a "apt install uptimed; apt remove uptimed; apt install uptimed" sequence results in a non-running uptimed.service. I then followed the hints from Niels and tried the attached patch. It seems to fix the issue at hand. I'd be interested to know, how the release team would like to this issue handled. While I did spot a few false positives when glancing over the list (e.g. packages which use --no-start, so are not affected), I would expect the majority of packages to be affected. I can offer to do a MBF if the release team thinks this issue is important enough to be fixed for buster. As the original bug reporter of #887904 I should have probably done that much earlier. Apologies for raising this topic this late in the release cycle. Regards, Michael -- Why is it that all of the instruments seeking intelligent life in the universe are pointed away from Earth?
acpid-2.0.31 alljoyn-core-1504-15.04b+dfsg.1 alljoyn-core-1509-15.09a+dfsg.1 alljoyn-core-1604-16.04a+dfsg.1 alsa-utils-1.1.8 anacron-2.3 anytun-0.3.7 apache-directory-server-2.0.0~M24 apcupsd-3.14.14 apertium-apy-0.11.4 apparmor-2.13.2 arno-iptables-firewall-2.0.3 arpon-3.0-ng+dfsg1 arpwatch-2.1a15 autolog-0.40+debian bip-0.9.0~rc3 bitz-server-2.0.3 booth-1.0-162-g27f917f bzflag-2.4.18 certmonger-0.79.6 clamav-0.101.2+dfsg clamsmtp-1.10 cluster-glue-1.0.12 connman-1.36 conntrack-tools-1.4.5 coturn-4.5.1.1 courier-1.0.6 courier-authlib-0.69.0 cups-filters-1.21.6 curvedns-0.87 dbab-1.3.2 dbus-1.12.12 debomatic-0.24 dhcpcd5-7.1.0 diamond-4.0.515 dico-2.7 dkimpy-milter-1.0.1 dnssec-trigger-0.17+repack docker.io-18.09.1+dfsg1 dovecot-2.3.4.1 downtimed-1.0 dphys-swapfile-20100506 earlyoom-1.2 ejabberd-18.12.1 etbemon-1.3.3 etcd-3.2.26+dfsg fastnetmon-1.1.3+dfsg fcgiwrap-1.1.0 fcoe-utils-1.0.31+git20160622.5dfd3e4 fio-3.12 firebird3.0-3.0.5.33100.ds4 firehol-3.1.6+ds game-data-packager-63 gdnsd-2.4.2 gfarm-2.7.11+dfsg glances-3.1.0 goiardi-0.11.9 greenbone-security-assistant-7.0.3+dfsg.1 groonga-9.0.0 h2o-2.2.5+dfsg2 heartbeat-3.0.6 htpdate-1.2.0 ifupdown-extra-0.28 inputlirc-30 ipmitool-1.8.18 iptables-persistent-1.0.11 isso-0.12.2 iwatch-0.2.2 jabberd2-2.7.0 jetty9-9.4.15 keepalived-2.0.10 kgb-bot-1.54 knot-2.7.6 laptop-mode-tools-1.72 lbcd-3.5.2 lemonldap-ng-2.0.2+ds lirc-0.10.1 lizardfs-3.12.0+dfsg lldpad-1.0.1+git20180808.4e642bd lvm2-2.03.02 lxc-3.1.0+really3.0.3 lxcfs-3.0.3 mailavenger-0.8.5 mailgraph-1.14 mailman-suite-0+20180916 mailman3-3.2.1 mdadm-4.1 minetest-0.4.17.1+repack monopd-0.10.2 mosquitto-1.5.7 munge-0.5.13 natlog-2.01.01 ndisc6-1.0.4 net-snmp-5.7.3+dfsg netconsole-0.2 netdiag-1.2 nethack-3.6.1 nomad-0.8.7+dfsg1 nsd-4.1.26 ocfs2-tools-1.8.5 opa-fm-10.8.0.0.202+dfsg.1 open-vm-tools-10.3.10 openntpd-6.2p3 opensmtpd-6.0.3p1 openvas-manager-7.0.3 openvas-scanner-5.1.3 openvpn-2.4.7 osmo-ggsn-1.2.2 ovirt-guest-agent-1.0.15.dfsg owfs-3.2p3+dfsg1 pacemaker-2.0.1 pagekite-0.5.9.3 pcs-0.10.1 pcsc-lite-1.8.24 pdns-recursor-4.1.11 policyd-rate-limit-1.0.0 ppp-2.4.7 prometheus-2.7.1+ds prometheus-alertmanager-0.15.3+ds prometheus-apache-exporter-0.5.0+ds prometheus-bind-exporter-0.2~git20161221+dfsg prometheus-blackbox-exporter-0.13.0+ds prometheus-haproxy-exporter-0.9.0+git20180917+ds prometheus-mongodb-exporter-1.0.0+git20180522.e755a44 prometheus-mysqld-exporter-0.11.0+ds prometheus-node-exporter-0.17.0+ds prometheus-postgres-exporter-0.4.7+ds prometheus-pushgateway-0.7.0+ds prosody-0.11.2 puppet-5.5.10 puppetdb-6.2.0 quota-4.04 radioclk-1.0.pristine radsecproxy-1.7.2 rdma-core-22.1 redsocks-0.5 resource-agents-4.2.0 robustirc-bridge-1.8 rpcbind-1.2.5 rspamd-1.8.1 salt-2018.3.4~git20180207+dfsg1 samba-4.9.5+dfsg sane-backends-1.0.27 sbd-1.4.0 scanbd-1.5.1 schleuder-3.4.0 sddm-0.18.0 setserial-2.17 shairport-sync-3.2.2 sks-1.1.6 slurm-llnl-18.08.5.2 smartmontools-6.6 sndio-1.5.0 softflowd-0.9.9 sogo-4.0.7 sopel-6.6.3 spampd-2.53 sshguard-2.3.1 supervisor-3.3.5 suricata-4.1.2 swapspace-1.14 sympa-6.2.40~dfsg sysstat-12.0.3 tgt-1.0.74 tinyproxy-1.10.0 trafficserver-8.0.2+ds tuptime-3.5.0 ulogd2-2.0.7 unicorn-5.4.1 uptimed-0.4.1 util-linux-2.33.1 vblade-24 vnstat-1.18 wdm-1.28 webdis-0.1.4+dfsg weborf-0.15 wesnoth-1.14-1.14.5 wicd-1.7.4+tb2 wireless-tools-30~pre9 writeboost-1.20170616 x2goserver-4.1.0.3 xpra-2.4.3+dfsg1 xrdp-0.9.9 yadifa-2.3.8 zabbix-4.0.4+dfsg
diff -Nru uptimed-0.4.1/debian/control uptimed-0.4.1/debian/control
--- uptimed-0.4.1/debian/control 2019-02-19 22:00:49.000000000 +0100
+++ uptimed-0.4.1/debian/control 2019-04-30 16:07:36.000000000 +0200
@@ -3,7 +3,7 @@
Priority: optional
Maintainer: Axel Beckert <abe@debian.org>
Build-Depends: automake,
- debhelper (>= 11),
+ debhelper (>= 12),
docbook-utils,
dpkg-dev (>> 1.16.1~),
libtool,
diff -Nru uptimed-0.4.1/debian/rules uptimed-0.4.1/debian/rules
--- uptimed-0.4.1/debian/rules 2019-02-19 22:04:07.000000000 +0100
+++ uptimed-0.4.1/debian/rules 2019-04-30 16:09:26.000000000 +0200
@@ -20,3 +20,9 @@
override_dh_auto_build:
dh_auto_build
cd debian && LC_ALL=C onsgmls uptimed.conf.sgml | sgmlspl sgmlspl-specs/docbook2man-spec.pl
+
+override_dh_installsystemd:
+ DH_COMPAT=12 dh_installsystemd
+
+override_dh_installinit:
+ DH_COMPAT=12 dh_installinit
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature