[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#504357: marked as done ([UDD] debvercmp.sql incorrectly implements the versions comparison system)

Your message dated Tue, 4 Nov 2008 11:02:26 +0100
with message-id <20081104100226.GA7985@xanadu.blop.info>
and subject line Re: Bug#504357: [UDD] debvercmp.sql incorrectly implements the versions comparison system
has caused the Debian Bug report #504357,
regarding [UDD] debvercmp.sql incorrectly implements the versions comparison system
to be marked as done.

This means that you claim that the problem has been dealt with.
If this is not the case it is now your responsibility to reopen the
Bug report if necessary, and/or fix the problem forthwith.

(NB: If you are a system administrator and have no idea what this
message is talking about, this may indicate a serious mail system
misconfiguration somewhere. Please contact owner@bugs.debian.org
immediately.)


-- 
504357: http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=504357
Debian Bug Tracking System
Contact owner@bugs.debian.org with problems
--- Begin Message --- 
Package: qa.debian.org
User: qa.debian.org@packages.debian.org
Usertags: udd

Hi,

This is mostly for those working directly on udd (lucas, HE, zack, christian, 
kurt, etc). The implementation of deb/vercmp is incorrectly comparing a 
couple of versions, and for others it is returning a value other than -1, 0, 
or 1.

Attached is the execution log of my test suite, which is now available at
http://git.debian.org/?p=users/atomo64-guest/misc-devscripts.git

Cheers,
-- 
Raphael Geissert - Debian Maintainer
www.debian.org - get.debian.net

udd.pl failed test 'foo- foo 0'/tests/foo with '1'
udd.pl failed test 'foo- foo+ -1'/tests/foo with '1'
udd.pl failed test '3.3-1.1 3.1-1 1 acl2'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.8.0-1 0.6.1-1 1 clutter-gst'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.2.4-1 0.2.2-2 1 apt-cacher-ng'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.7.32 1.7.30 1 crosshurd'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.15 0.13 1 apt-xapian-index'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.0.5-1 2.0.3-3 1 atl2'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.93 1.91 1 base-installer'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '6.2.14-1 6.2.12-1 1 boinc'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.2.dfsg-6 1.2.dfsg-4 1 calendarserver'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.133 0.131 1 cdebconf'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.93.3.dfsg-1 0.93.1.dfsg-1.1 1 clamav'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.8.0-1 0.6.4-1 1 clutter'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.8.2-1 0.6.2-1 1 clutter-cairo'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.8.1-1 0.6.1-1 1 clutter-gtk'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.8.0.1-1 0.6.0.0-1 1 clutter-perl'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.27 1.25 1 console-setup'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.4-36 1.4-34 1 cpuburn'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2:1.0.6-6 2:1.0.6-4 1 cryptsetup'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '7.18.2-7 7.18.2-5 1 curl'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '4.0.4 4.0.2 1 debian-faq'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.1-20080727-1 1.1-20080316-1 1 dialog'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '4'
udd.pl failed test '0.98.12 0.98.10 1 dictionaries-common'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '28-2 26-2 1 dwm-tools'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '53-2 50-4 1 ecryptfs-utils'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '28.0-1 26.0-3 1 emacspeak'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.8.29-1 0.8.27-1 1 foreign'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.82-4 0.63-3.4 1 freetds'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '3.0+4.0.2-5 3.0+4.0.2-3 1 fslview'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.6.2-6 1.6.2-4 1 funkload'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.09-1 0.07-2 1 garmin-forerunner-tools'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '4.3.1-8 4.3.1-2 1 gcc-4.3'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '6'
udd.pl failed test '2.2.6-1 2.2.4-1 1 gnucash'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.16.3-3 1.16.1-2 1 gnustep-base'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.10~pre4-5 2.10~pre4-3 1 gpsdrive'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.97-46 0.97-44 1 grub'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.8-8 0.8-6 1 gvidm'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.1.3-8 2.1.3-6 1 heartbeat'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.65 1.62 1 hw-detect'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '0.6.5-5 0.6.5-3 1 i810switch'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1:2.0.0.16+debian-1 1:2.0.0.14+debian-1 1 icedove-l10n'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.56 2.53 1 ikiwiki'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '0.0.0.20080713-1 0.0.0.20080510-1 1 josm'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.4.2-2 0.2.0-6 1 kaya'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.59.3-1 0.52.3-1 1 kde-style-qtcurve'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '7'
udd.pl failed test '2.48 2.45 1 kernel-wedge'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '6.3-6 6.3-4 1 kfreebsd-6'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.17-13-1 0.17-10-1 1 lattice'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '1.607-1 1.605-1 1 libdbi-perl'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '3.43-1 3.41-1 1 libev'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2008-1 2006-1 1 libflorist'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.6.9-8 2.6.9-6 1 libpqxx'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.0.65-4 2.0.65-2 1 libselinux'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.2.80-95-3 2.2.80-95-1 1 libspe2'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.77-2 2.70-1 1 libsvn-notify-perl'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '7'
udd.pl failed test '1.26-1 1.22-1 1 libthreads-shared-perl'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '4'
udd.pl failed test '0.5-1 0.3-8 1 libtree-redblack-perl'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.8.3-1 0.5.2.0-3 1 libxml-ruby'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '1.27 1.23 1 linux-kernel-di-arm-2.6'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '4'
udd.pl failed test '1.19 1.15 1 linux-kernel-di-armel-2.6'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '4'
udd.pl failed test '1.28 1.24 1 linux-kernel-di-hppa-2.6'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '4'
udd.pl failed test '1.66 1.61 1 linux-kernel-di-i386-2.6'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '5'
udd.pl failed test '0.29 0.25 1 linux-kernel-di-mips-2.6'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '4'
udd.pl failed test '0.29 0.25 1 linux-kernel-di-mipsel-2.6'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '4'
udd.pl failed test '0.27 0.23 1 linux-kernel-di-s390-2.6'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '4'
udd.pl failed test '1.13 1.11 1 linux-modules-di-amd64-2.6'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.13 1.11 1 linux-modules-di-i386-2.6'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.3.8-1 0.3.6-4 1 liquidsoap'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '7 5 1 live-installer'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.999375-24-1 0.999375-22-1 1 lme4'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '3.2-19 3.2-12 1 lsb'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '7'
udd.pl failed test '0.98.3-2 0.98.1-1 1 matplotlib'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '5.15.0-2 5.13.0-3.1 1 maxima'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.3.9 0.3.7 1 modconf'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.0.7-3 2.0.7-1 1 nano'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.85.dfsg1-4 0.85.dfsg1-1 1 nant'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '1.1-3 1.1-1 1 ncurses-ruby'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.3.1-4 1.3.1-2 1 ndoc'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.19 1.16 1 network-console'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '4.68-1 4.62-1 1 nmap'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '6'
udd.pl failed test '2.11b-7 2.11b-3 1 noweb'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '4'
udd.pl failed test '2.4.7+dfsg-2 2.2.8-2 1 nunit'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.2.2-6 2.2.2-2 1 nut'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '4'
udd.pl failed test '1.4.9.dfsg1-1 1.4.6.dfsg1-1 1 ogre'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '0.0.16-1 0.0.13-1 1 ooolib-python'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '2.2.6+dfsg-3 2.2.6+dfsg-1 1 opencryptoki'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.0+r655-1 0.0+r423-1 1 openocd'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.16 1.14 1 palo'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.28 1.26 1 partconf'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '124 120 1 partman-base'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '4'
udd.pl failed test '34 32 1 partman-crypto'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '5.10.0-13 5.10.0-11.1 1 perl'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.3-1 2.1-1 1 pexpect'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.1.0.5-6 1.1.0.5-3 1 phpldapadmin'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '1.82-2 1.80-2.3 1 postfix-policyd'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.38 1.36 1 preseed'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.8.24-4 0.8.24-2.1 1 pump'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.0.18.3 2.0.18.1 1 pygopherd'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.4.6-1 0.4.4-2 1 pyroman'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.2.4-1 1.2.2-3.1 1 python-bibtex'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.47-1 1.45-3 1 python-biopython'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.3.3-1 2.3.1-6 1 python-dns'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.4.5-5 2.4.5-3 1 python2.4'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.0.5.0-1-4 2.0.5.0-1-2.1 1 qcad'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.12.5-5 2.12.1-2 1 quick-lounge-applet'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '4'
udd.pl failed test '0.7-7-1 0.7-4-1 1 r-cran-vgam'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '2.20080801-1 2.20080629-1 1 redhat-cluster'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.11-4 0.11-1 1 refit'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '1.3.2-5 1.3.2-3 1 rkhunter'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.4-2-1 0.2-8-2 1 robustbase'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.64 1.62 1 rootskel'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.14 1.12 1 rootskel-gtk'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.0.19-17 1.0.19-15 1 sane-backends'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '5.0.6.dfsg-2 5.0.1.dfsg-1 1 scotch'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '5'
udd.pl failed test '4.1.5-8 4.1.5-6 1 sed'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.6-6 0.6-4 1 stegdetect'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '4.5.17+cvs080723-2 4.5.15-1.2 1 strace'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.0+r3432-1 0.0+r3125-1 1 superiotool'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '1.3.36-1 1.3.33-3 1 swig1.3'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '1.019-4 1.019-2 1 sympow'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.0.20080710-1 0.0.20080122-1 1 trac-git'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '6'
udd.pl failed test '1.1.4-4 1.1.2-1 1 trackballs'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '2.25-3 2.25-1 1 ttf-dejavu'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1:5.1.20080808-1 1:1.0-4 1 unifont'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '4'
udd.pl failed test '0.89b-5 0.85-24 1 vdr-plugin-bitstreamout'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '4'
udd.pl failed test '0.9.6-1 0.9.4.20080717-1 1 viking'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1:0.16.14-3 1:0.16.14-1 1 vte'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.0.7-3 1.0.5-1 1 xapian-bindings'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.0.7-3 1.0.5-1 1 xapian-core'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.0.7-3 1.0.5-1 1 xapian-omega'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '3.02-2 1.08-3 1 xnee'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.24-1 0.22-1 1 yahoo2mbox'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '0.5.45 0.5.42 1 zope-common'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '2.5-3 2.5-1 1 dbus-java'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '1.9-5 1.9-1 1 jcc'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '4'
udd.pl failed test '1.4.9-1 1.4.6-1 1 ogre-contrib'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '20080707-3 20080411-1 1 ion3'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '2.4-5 2.4-2 1 ixp4xx-microcode'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '3'
udd.pl failed test '2.2.3-4 2.2.3-2 1 openmotif'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed test '3.80-2 3.67-4 1 tth'/tests/versions.lenny-sid with '2'
udd.pl failed 141 over 731 tests

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.


--- End Message ---
--- Begin Message --- 
On 03/11/08 at 19:45 -0600, Raphael Geissert wrote:
> 
> Hi Lucas,
> 
> Lucas Nussbaum wrote:
> > 
> > Hi Raphael,
> > 
> > Do you know a perl implementation that works fine ?
> 
> Debbugs' (which is almost exactly the same as dpkg-dev's, differring by some bug
> fixes) passes the test suite.

OK. I switched to debbugs' code, and checked that the result looks
better now.

however, your testsuite result is a bit confusing. Could you switch to
something like:
udd.pl failed test '3.3-1.1 3.1-1 1 acl2'/tests/versions.lenny-sid (expected 1, got 2)
-- 
| Lucas Nussbaum
| lucas@lucas-nussbaum.net   http://www.lucas-nussbaum.net/ |
| jabber: lucas@nussbaum.fr             GPG: 1024D/023B3F4F |

--- End Message ---
Reply to: