Le mer 23 août 2006 12:16, Christian Perrier a écrit : > > Why would I do that, when you are taking the opposite way? When you > > believe a commend on a list has no merit, you explicitly ask other > > people to ignore it, based on a stupid DD/non-DD segregation > > instead of the merits of the comment. > > This is not my understanding of aj's comment, Josselin. He did not > ask to *ignore* Peter's comment, but only to remind that, Peter not > being a DD, the comment can't be told to reflect the DD community > opinion. This is still how many people (me included) do perceive it. Moreover, the fact that the opinion that Peter expressed is widespread or not among the DDs is also irrelevant to the discussion. The discussion is about what options we have, and the the GR will be responsible to see which opinion is the most shared among the DD comunity. Until the vote, anybody can express his views opinions, even if it is a minority position ... that is what a public debate really is about. With that in mind, beeing a DD or not is a completely irrelevant information, and reminding is, whichever the original intention of that reminder was, is rude and inappropriate. That's not the first tham that aj does such reminders[1], and especiall beeing the DPL[2], I find that disturbing. Regards, [1] remember the ugly java thread ... [2] that does not mean that it's ok to do such remarks not beeing the DPL, it means that having such words as the DPL makes it worse. -- ·O· Pierre Habouzit ··O madcoder@debian.org OOO http://www.madism.org
Attachment:
pgpljshqaaI8r.pgp
Description: PGP signature