Re: Debian and Zapping recording
>>>>> "emm" == Eduardo Marcel Macan <macan@debian.org> writes:
emm> That is probably going away when ALSA + JACK becomes the
emm> standard, I think we should start to help their adoption by
emm> the upstream authors of the sound software we use...
This is not always as simple as it might seem, as JACK per se imposes
quite a different approach to audio applications, which are normally
blocking I/O based.
libjackasyn by Guenter allows `legacy' audio applications to use Jack
via a LD_PRELOAD trick (Guenter, corrects me if I'm wrong).
Besides, latest ALSA versions have started working on a Jack driver so
that in theory you could connect ALSA output to Jack (I haven't tested
it, so again Guenter or anybody who actually is more knowledgeable
than me should beat me on the head).
emm> I don't think of jack as something as simple as a "sound
emm> daemon", so it makes sense to me that even other sound
emm> daemons like esd should have jack output plugins. I didn't
emm> check to see if it already has...
esd has been unmaintained for a long time, AFAIK (although it's still
the default GNOME sound server). There is a `replacement' project,
asd, but I don't know how far they have gone.
Last time I checked I think GNOME was thinking about switching to
arTs, which is not strictly KDE related.
However, I do agree with you that we should ask upstreams to switch to
Jack (as an added option). One thing we are (slowly) going to do
within AGNULA is an application database, noting which `sound system'
each one can use.
bye,
andrea
--
Andrea Glorioso andrea.glorioso@agnula.org
AGNULA/DeMuDi Technical Manager http://www.agnula.org/
"There's no free expression without control on the tools you use"
Reply to: