[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#906536: Sponsor for my package "cavestory-nx"

(dropping list from CC)

On Sun, Aug 26, 2018 at 05:04:36PM -0300, Carlos Donizete Froes wrote:
> Hi,
> > You cannot just drop paragraphs from d/copyright at will, it needs to
> > be backed up by a statement of the copyright owners.
> Sorry, I did not understand the previously replied email
> and I ended up removing it.

Yes, you misunderstood me on this occasion. I tried to do two things:
a) highlight that there was some desire from the author for NC license
that needs confirming, e.g. maybe they want it to be CC-BY-NC?
b) point out, as Tobi did, that you need some public documentation of
the authors intent in order to document that in the copyright

> > Can you, by change, forward the original statement of "pixel", on which
> > basis you wrote d/copyright, to this bug/list?
> Yes, follows the forwarded message.

What we're looking for here is an unambiguous public declaration of the
license from Pixel. I'm afraid the forwarded email doesn't satisfy that.
It's confusing regarding Cave Story/Vorbis and MIT/BSD and nothing in it
mentions Public Domain.

It seems theres some language barrier here, but first you need to find
out what terms the author is after (I'm assuming here that it's art and
not software), the most basic starting point is this:


Only after the author has decided on terms can they go about choosing a
license, which may or may not be public domain, but if it is, there
needs to be a clear public statement of that, e.g. the CC0 waiver I

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: PGP signature

Reply to: