Post-Receive Hooks
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA512
Hi,
I noticed the other day that some debian-astro repositories were using
the debian-science post-receive hooks, rather than their own, leading to
things like deb.li links posted by KB in #debian-science pointing to
non-existent repositories. This prompted me to look through all the
repositories in debian-astro, debichem, debian-med and debian-science,
tabulating the results to see how consistent they are. The results vary
between the different teams, and are attached file, but here is a
summary of my findings:
1. A lot of debian-astro packages are calling debian-science's
post-receive. This seems like a bad thing to do, especially given
debian-astro has its own post-receive that seems to have been forked
from debian-science (though may need updating, along with the KGB
config).
2. Many packages lack any post-receive hooks. This is easy to fix, and I
can't think of any reasons why this would be preferable for public
repositories.
3. Many packages just call /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice. Given each
team has its own post-receive hook which does this, I again see no
good reason for these not to use the correct hook.
i. A few call git-post-receive-tag-pending as well (via pee(1)). I
doubt maintainers would be very happy if this was done for every
package, even though I am strongly in favour of the script (or forks
thereof).
4. As you might expect, there are a few special snowflakes, including a
few which I lack permission to read.
5. The official Debian Science policy is quite outdated when it comes to
the section on repositories[1]. It has no mention of the
setup-repository script, and encourages people to use
/usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice, rather than
debian-science-post-receive. If people are ok with it, I would be
willing to update this.
Regards,
James
[1] http://debian-science.alioth.debian.org/debian-science-policy.html#idm46065384004448
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----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=p5BY
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----Debian Science and Related Teams - Post-Receive Hooks (2016-04-27)
=====================================================
Debian Astro
------------
aplpy.git No post-receive hook
astlib.git No post-receive hook
astromatic.git No post-receive hook
astrometry-data-2mass.git No post-receive hook
astrometry.net.git No post-receive hook
astroml-addons.git No post-receive hook
astroml.git No post-receive hook
astroquery.git No post-receive hook
astroscrappy.git No post-receive hook
casacore-data.git No post-receive hook
casacore.git No post-receive hook
ccdproc.git No post-receive hook
coyote.git No post-receive hook
cpl.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
cpl-plugin-amber.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
cpl-plugin-fors.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
cpl-plugin-giraf.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
cpl-plugin-hawki.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
cpl-plugin-kmos.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
cpl-plugin-muse.git No post-receive hook
cpl-plugin-naco.git No post-receive hook
cpl-plugin-sinfo.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
cpl-plugin-template.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
cpl-plugin-uves.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
cpl-plugin-vimos.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
cpl-plugin-visir.git No post-receive hook
cpl-plugin-xsh.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
crush.git No post-receive hook
debian-astro.git No post-receive hook
emcee.git No post-receive hook
erfa.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
eso-midas.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
eso-pipelines.git No post-receive hook
esorex.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
fitscut.git No post-receive hook
fitspng.git No post-receive hook
fitsverify.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
ftools-fv.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
funtools.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
gadget2.git No post-receive hook
gammapy.git No post-receive hook
glue.git No post-receive hook
gnudatalanguage.git No post-receive hook
gravit.git No post-receive hook
gyoto.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
iausofa.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
idlastro.git No post-receive hook
iraf.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
jsamp.git No post-receive hook
missfits.git No post-receive hook
montage.git No post-receive hook
montage-wrapper.git No post-receive hook
mpfit.git No post-receive hook
neat.git No post-receive hook
photutils.git No post-receive hook
psfex.git No post-receive hook
pyavm.git No post-receive hook
pyephem.git No post-receive hook
pyregion.git No post-receive hook
pysynphot.git No post-receive hook
python-asdf.git No post-receive hook
python-astropy-affiliated.git No post-receive hook
python-astropy.git /home/groups/debian-astro/bin/debian-astro-post-receive
python-astropy-helpers.git No post-receive hook
python-cpl.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
python-fitsio.git No post-receive hook
python-pyds9.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
python-pyraf.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
python-pywcs.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
rawtran.git No post-receive hook
reproject.git No post-receive hook
saods9.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
scamp.git No post-receive hook
sextractor.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
siril.git No post-receive hook
skycat.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
spectral-cube.git No post-receive hook
specutils.git No post-receive hook
splash.git No post-receive hook
starlink-ast.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
starlink-pal.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
stellarium.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
stellarium-legacy.git No post-receive hook
stellarium-stars.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
stiff.git No post-receive hook
sunpy.git No post-receive hook
swarp.git No post-receive hook
tcl-fitstcl.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
tycho2.git No post-receive hook
wcsaxes.git No post-receive hook
wcslib.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
wcstools.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
weightwatcher.git No post-receive hook
x11iraf.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
xpa.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
yorick-yao.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
yt.git No post-receive hook
Summary
-------
59 No post-receive hook
34 /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
3 exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
1 /home/groups/debian-astro/bin/debian-astro-post-receive
--
97
--
DebiChem
--------
biceps.git exec /git/debian-med/git-commit-notice
chemps2.git No post-receive hook
comet-ms.git /home/groups/debichem/bin/debichem-post-receive
gpaw.git No post-receive hook
gpaw-setups.git /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
hekate.git /home/groups/debichem/bin/debichem-post-receive
lhendraw.git No post-receive hook
libmasstoolkit.git No post-receive hook
libpwiz.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
libwildmagic.git /home/groups/debichem/bin/debichem-post-receive
lutefisk.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
masschroq.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
massxpert.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
mmass.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
molequeue.git /home/groups/debichem/bin/debichem-post-receive
openmm.git /home/groups/debichem/bin/debichem-post-receive
openms.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
p4vasp.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
python-ase.git /home/groups/debichem/bin/debichem-post-receive
python-griddataformats.git No post-receive hook
python-mdanalysis.git No post-receive hook
python-mzml.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
r-cran-base64enc.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
r-cran-downloader.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
r-cran-maldiquantforeign.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
r-cran-maldiquant.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
r-cran-mixtools.git /home/groups/debichem/bin/debichem-post-receive
r-cran-readbrukerflexdata.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
r-cran-readmzxmldata.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
r-other-amsmercury.git /home/groups/debichem/bin/debichem-post-receive
r-other-curvefdp.git /home/groups/debichem/bin/debichem-post-receive
r-other-iwrlars.git /home/groups/debichem/bin/debichem-post-receive
r-other-nitpick.git /home/groups/debichem/bin/debichem-post-receive
tandem-mass.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
viewmol.git /home/groups/debichem/bin/debichem-post-receive
Summary
-------
15 exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
12 /home/groups/debichem/bin/debichem-post-receive
6 No post-receive hook
1 /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive
1 exec /git/debian-med/git-commit-notice
--
35
--
Debian Med
----------
(Repositories that call /git/debian-med/git-commit-notice are omitted)
debian-med.git No post-receive hook
emboss.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
igv.git No post-receive hook
ncbi-tools6.git No post-receive hook
pesco.git No post-receive hook
samtools.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
sitplus.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
users/corentin-guest.git No post-receive hook
users/sergiodj-guest.git No post-receive hook
users/spectra.git Cannot read post-receive hook (permission denied)
Summary
-------
402 exec /git/debian-med/git-commit-notice
6 No post-receive hook
3 exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
1 Cannot read post-receive hook (permission denied)
---
412
---
Debian Science
--------------
(Repositories that call debian-science-post-receive are omitted)
adk2tool.git No post-receive hook
adolc.git No post-receive hook
ape.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
apertium-cat.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
apertium-dan.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
apertium-fra.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
apertium.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
apertium-nno.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
apertium-nno-nob.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
apertium-nob.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
apertium-sme-nob.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
apertium-swe.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
arduino-mk.git No post-receive hook
ask.git No post-receive hook
atompaw.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
bliss.git No post-receive hook
bossa.git No post-receive hook
cbflib.git Functionally empty post-receive hook (just comments)
ccd.git No post-receive hook
ceres-solver.git No post-receive hook
cg3.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
ckon.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
coinmp.git No post-receive hook
colpack.git No post-receive hook
dx.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
dxsamples.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
eigen2.git exec /git/pkg-kde/git-commit-notice
elmer-doc.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
engrid.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
fcl.git No post-receive hook
flintqs.git No post-receive hook
foma.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
gavodachs.git No post-receive hook
geneagrapher.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
gfm.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
giac.git Calls /usr/local/bin/git-post-receive-tag-pending, and the seemingly non-existent /usr/local/bin/git-post-receive-diff?
giella-core.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
giella-sme.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
gpaw.git No post-receive hook
gummi.git exec pee /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice /usr/local/bin/git-post-receive-tag-pending
h5py.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
hfst.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
hfst-ospell.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
hmat-oss.git No post-receive hook
ismrmrd.old.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
kst.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
libfox95.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
libticables.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
libticalcs.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
libticonv.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
libtifiles.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
libvigraimpex.git exec pee /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice /usr/local/bin/git-post-receive-tag-pending
linop.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
linsmith.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
lttoolbox.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
mathicgb.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
mathic.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
netcdfc.git No post-receive hook
nfft.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
nltk.git exec pee /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice /usr/local/bin/git-post-receive-tag-pending
nufft.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
o2scl.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
octomap.git No post-receive hook
openctm.git No post-receive hook
opencv.git No post-receive hook
pfft.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
pnfft.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
pyfftw.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
pynfft.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
pyoperators.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
python-expyriment.git No post-receive hook
quadrule.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
qucs.git No post-receive hook
rbdl.git No post-receive hook
r-cran-gbm.git No post-receive hook
r-cran-lhs.git No post-receive hook
r-cran-pbdzmq.git No post-receive hook
r-cran-r6.git No post-receive hook
r-cran-tgp.git No post-receive hook
r-cran-uuid.git No post-receive hook
r-cran-vcdextra.git No post-receive hook
rubiks.git No post-receive hook
sagemath-database-combinatorial-designs.git No post-receive hook
scatterplot3d.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
scoop.git exec pee /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice /usr/local/bin/git-post-receive-tag-pending
spglib.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
stp.git No post-receive hook
su2.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
svgtoipe.git No post-receive hook
sympy.git No post-receive hook
syrthes.git Calls /usr/local/bin/git-post-receive-tag-pending, and the seemingly non-existent /usr/local/bin/git-post-receive-diff?
tiemu.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
tilem.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
tilp2.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
toulbar2.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
travatar.git No post-receive hook
ufo-core.git Can't read; permission denied (actual repo is in debian-pan, this is just a symlink)
vishnu.git No post-receive hook
wannier90.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
xmds2.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
yoda.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
yorick-gy.git No post-receive hook
yorick-yao.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
yorick-ygsl.git exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
yorick-ynfft.git No post-receive hook
Summary
-------
681 exec /home/groups/debian-science/bin/debian-science-post-receive (including without exec)
58 exec /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice
38 No post-receive hook
4 exec pee /usr/local/bin/git-commit-notice /usr/local/bin/git-post-receive-tag-pending
2 Calls /usr/local/bin/git-post-receive-tag-pending, and the seemingly non-existent /usr/local/bin/git-post-receive-diff?
1 exec /git/pkg-kde/git-commit-notice
1 Can't read; permission denied (actual repo is in debian-pan, this is just a symlink)
1 Functionally empty post-receive hook (just comments)
---
786
---
Reply to: