Re: Bug#656573: RM: freediams -- ROM; Non-free data used in package
Le 24 janv. 2012 à 20:58, Andreas Tille a écrit :
> Hi Alexander,
> On Tue, Jan 24, 2012 at 06:34:42PM +0100, Alexander Reichle-Schmehl wrote:
>>> I'm not an FTP master, though.
>> As far as I can see, the package is indeed distributable, but not fit
>> for main.
> Thanks for inspecting the package. While this is not the best possible
> option it is at least helpful.
>> I therefore close the bug cloned for snapshot.d.o (sorry for the noise)
>> and will remove the package from main soonish.
> If you say "remove from main" does this mean that you will move it to
> non-free automatically.
This can be a very good plan, even if we have to make an update (a debug version) of the package: 0.4.2 and 0.5.4. We finally just need to include the licence/copyright to the debian files.
> I guess not because it would probably need a
> change in debian/control, but just to make sure. I would plan to split
> the original upstream source into the database part for non-free and
> the code for contrib - but needs to negotiate this with upstream.
For the previous release of FreeDiams, this can be a good option, because the application can be used without the database.
>> Yes, fit for non-free not for main. And the whole license should be
>> added to debian/copyright (and an unofficial translation would be
>> usefull, too).
> In my mail I just quoted the current debian/copyright in SVN - so this
> is basically done (except for the translation).
I can add this unofficial translation. Should I replace the french licence terms or should I leave them and add the english translation ?
>>> What's the problem with that? The missing license to allow
>>> modification? Even then it would still be distributable, which is
>>> distinct from not belonging into main.
>> Well, in some legislations "reproduction" includes limited modifications
>> rights, however not enough for main (and not in .eu). So yes, unfit for
>> main, unless clarified to include rights for modifications.
> Well, if we have one single part non-dirstributable for main the whole
> database can not be distributed in main. Upstream assembled them all
> in one single file and claimed there is no chance to split it up into
> a free and a non-free part.
For the future release of the FreeMedForms project apps, the non-free (according to the DSC) data will be downloadable directly from the application. Applications will be packaged with a sample of free data (so that user can test functionnalities).
For the current and the previous versions, we can not provide a free package and a non-free.
Eric Maeker, MD (Fr)
http://www.freemedforms.com : Suite logicielle médicale open source
http://asso.freemedforms.com : Association 1901 des utilisateurs de la suite FreeMedForms
http://wiki.debian.org/DebianMed : Debian Med est une distribution Debian orientée médecine
http://www.ericmaeker.fr : site personnel