I used to be a flag-waving FSF patriot, but for reasons people familiar with the present GFDL GR debate will appreciate, the FSF has lost my trust. My question is as follows. The FSF retains special authority unilaterally to extend the GPL, LGPL, FDL, etc. For my own free software, can I take this special authority away from the FSF and transfer it to the Debian Project? That is, can I license my software with This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU General Public License; either the Free Software Foundation's version 2, or (at your option, without regard to FSF approval) any successor thereto the Debian Project has ever promulgated or approved. My intent, very regrettably, is to undermine my hero Richard M. Stallman's future credibility to speak on behalf of free-software developerdom, and to set a correct example for others who feel that they should do likewise. If so, then is my example correct? (With respect to the upcoming GR, for those whom it interests: For my own part, I will of course study the proposals in their final forms before deciding specifically how to vote, and I will pay close heed to the advice our top DDs offer. Generally, however, I admit that I reluctantly lean toward capitulating to the FSF in the GFDL matter. The FSF leadership is wrong, of course, and their behavior in ignoring Debian's just concerns in the matter for four years seems petulant and outrageous. Emotionally, I want forthrightly to oppose the FSF in the matter. Regrettably, however, it seems to me that the likely damage done to Debian for standing firmly against the GFDL now outweighs the important point of DFSG principle at stake here. We should now admit that, barring unforeseen developments, through no fault of our own leaders and delegates, the time to negotiate with the FSF has passed. We should either capitulate or defy without further delay. It has come to that point. The very reason I want to change the future license terms of my own software now is so that I don't unwittingly help the FSF to manipulate us in this way again.) Please advise. Also, if you feel that my analysis is misguided, overreactive or premature, feel free to argue (if I have had enough of the FSF's stonewalling, I still remain open to persuasion here; perhaps others feel likewise). Either way, respect Mail-Followup-To; copy replies to me. Thanks. -- Thaddeus H. Black 508 Nellie's Cave Road Blacksburg, Virginia 24060, USA +1 540 961 0920, t@b-tk.org, thb@debian.org
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: Digital signature