Hi everybody! Debconf5 should be finished now and I couldn't attend... :-( Thus, a few days ago I took a look at its website[1] and searched for published papers to read. I found the talks page[2] and some papers submitted by people who were going to give a talk. Sadly, their license status is really various and seldom DFSG-free. I feel it as a pity that many papers presented at Debconf5 are impossible[3] to ship in Debian main... Unfortunately the call for papers[4] does not mandate DFSG-compliance for the submitted papers.[5] I think that the next Debconf6 should require DFSG-compliance for the submitted papers. Do you agree? For Debconf5 instead, the situation was as follows a few days ago. Some papers are released under the GNU GPL (good news). Other papers are released under a non-free license or even have no license at all (which implicitly means All Rights Reserved!). Other papers are not released at all... The license table is: Paper title Author(s) License ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Debian release management Andreas Barth no one Debian Women and Women in... E.Clark, M.Onsoien no one Multiarch - An a proposal... Tollef Fog Heen [no paper] Debian-Kernel Team Overview... Dann Frazier GPLv2+ "DFSG-free" panel discussion Matthew Garrett [no info] Debian New Maintainer Process... Dafydd Harries [no paper] Securing the testing distr... Joey Hess GPL Linda - A Debian package... Steve Kowalik no one Debian Website Round Table Frank Lichtenheld no one Are we really devoted to... Margarita Manterola no one* Debian Installer - a... C.Perrier, H.Levsen, J.Hess GPL Custom Debian Distributions Andreas Tille [no paper] Debbugs, tips, tricks and hacks Anthony Towns CC-by-sa-v2.5** Debtags Enrico Zini GPLv2+ * moreover no source is provided (unless Margarita prefers to write directly in DVI...) ** this license has never been analysed on debian-legal but shares many unsolved issued with CC-by-sa-v2.0, which was judged to be non-free[6] I think that authors of unlicensed (and thus undistributable) papers, as well as authors of non-free papers should be contacted and /politely/ asked to republish their paper in a DFSG-free manner. Do you agree? Any volunteer to help me in privately contacting authors? There are only 6 papers to fix... Notes: [1] http://www.debconf.org/debconf5/ [2] http://www.debconf.org/debconf5/about/talks [3] whether packaging Debconf papers and distributing them in Debian is or isn't a good idea is entirely another question: what I'm concerned of here is "would it be possible from a Policy point of view?" [4] http://www.debconf.org/debconf5/news/call_for_papers [5] I thought it did mandate a license, but, upon rereading it, I noticed that the only statement that talks about licenses refers to live presentation recordings (and not to papers). [6] http://people.debian.org/~evan/ccsummary.html -- :-( This Universe is buggy! Where's the Creator's BTS? ;-) ...................................................................... Francesco Poli GnuPG Key ID = DD6DFCF4 Key fingerprint = C979 F34B 27CE 5CD8 DC12 31B5 78F4 279B DD6D FCF4
Attachment:
pgplf7csLasON.pgp
Description: PGP signature