[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: A possible approach in 'solving' the FDL problem

Josselin Mouette said:
> Le mer 13/08/2003 à 14:20, Sergey Spiridonov a écrit :
>> Yes, encrypted system will be a problem if I will try to sell
>> encrypted  FDL books, so that one can read, but not copy or modify his
>> copy.
> That was probably the intention, but the wording makes it unclear.
> However, everything depends on how the *software* author (not the
> license author) reads it. Without explicit clarification from the
> author of the FDL'ed stuff, the licensing is non-free.

Even with explicit clarification from the author, a license that depends on
the "free" interpretation by the author fails the DFSG "Tentacles of Evil"
If the author/copyright holder can change his interpretation (without
changing the license or the work licensed) and make the work non-free, then
the work is not free.

It's the difference between permission to "modify or distribute" and
permission to "distribute, modify, and/or distribute modified works".


Reply to: