[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: The debate on Invariant sections (long)

On Sun, May 25, 2003 at 01:49:07PM +1200, Adam Warner wrote:
> Frankly this claim that it is "always better to keep the manual
> separate"--as if it is always better to keep data separate from code--is a
> shocking and nonsensical claim from someone with such a distinguished Lisp
> background as yourself. I suppose for your next trick you'll claim
> ignorance of what Knuth achieved with literate programming.
> Don't think you can treat us all like fools by glossing over sound
> methodologies of documentation and software engineering in order to push
> the mandatory inclusion of your political texts.

Your message would have been better without these last two paragraphs.

Please try to maintain civility with Richard.  I sympathize with your
frustration but acerbic remarks like this do not help to remind him that
we, as a Project, are on the same side as he in most philosophical
battles of relevance to Debian's mission.

From a more selfish perspective, remarks like those quoted above make it
easier for RMS to be unfairly dismissive of our critiques of his
documentation licensing enterprise.  When you offer him bait like this,
he takes, while leaving more important, point-blank questions about the
motivations behind the GNU FDL answered.  I've asked these several
times[1] and he has yet to address them at all.  He just snips them out
of my mails, and doesn't reply to messages at all that contain nothing

An uncharitable interpretation of this phenomenon would be that RMS does
not think the community would be supportive of the GNU FDL if he were
frank about why he prefers it to the traditional GNU documentation
license.  However, there are other possible interpretations.

[1] for example:

G. Branden Robinson                |    There is no housing shortage in
Debian GNU/Linux                   |    Lincoln today -- just a rumor that
branden@debian.org                 |    is put about by people who have
http://people.debian.org/~branden/ |    nowhere to live.    -- G. L. Murfin

Attachment: pgpoWUAi5cS2F.pgp
Description: PGP signature

Reply to: