[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: [Pkg-samba-maint] Bug#650091: libpam-winbind package description



On 11/27/2011 03:17 AM, Jonathan Nieder wrote:
Jonathan Nieder wrote:

I assume that in practice, the main problem is that anyone searching
with "apt-cache search NetBIOS" is not going to find the package.
On second thought: looking over the current description of the winbind
package, I am already happy with it.  I guess libpam-winbind should
just say

  .
  This package provides PAM modules and NSS plugins to integrate
  winbind into the system's authentication and user/group/hostname
  lookup mechanisms.

and leave the talk of NetBIOS and detailed use cases to the "winbind"
package description.  For reference, here's that description, in case
someone has ideas for improvements.

Description: Samba nameservice integration server
  Samba is an implementation of the SMB/CIFS protocol [...]
  .
  This package provides winbindd, a daemon which integrates authentication
  and directory service (user/group lookup) mechanisms from a Windows
  domain on a Linux system.  User/group lookups are configured via
  /etc/nsswitch.conf, and authentication is integrated using the winbind
  module for PAM.

Winbind itself isn't actually related to NetBIOS, and doesn't provide any NetBIOS-related functionality. I don't think we should talk about NetBIOS in the winbind package description.

I'm not sure why libpam-wins is in the libpam-winbind package these days; I imagine most people who use winbind don't actually use libpam-wins. NetBIOS is usually only used in older style networks (DOS/Windows '95/'9x/), as people in newer networks will just rely on DNS. Winbind is exclusively used in domains (Windows NT 4 and up).

Cheers,

Jelemr


Reply to: