[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: [RFR] templates://ssl-cert/{templates}



> "Country's subdivision" doesn't work.  I'd suggest "political
> subdivision".

Hmmm, I'd prefer "Administrative subdivision" as such things aren't
really "political".


> 
> Given that the default countryName is GB, it would help if the
> DefaultChoice entry gave some hint as to how I would be expected to
> fill this in - "Scotland"?  "Lothian & Borders"?  "Midlothian"?  Or
> what?  I notice that my fellow Edinburgh resident Steve uses
> "Scotland" in "http://www.debian-administration.org/articles/349";, 

Hmmm, That should be one the ISO-3166-2 entries for the given country.

Using my iso-codes maintainer hat, I'd suggest we pick one of the
registered divisions for GB in that standard.

Of course, these things are complicated in GB as ISO-3166-2 lists
"First level divisions", namely Scotland, England, Wales, Northern
Ireland, Channel Islands, Isle of Man and "Divisions" which are
counties, London boroughs, metropolitan districts unitary authorities,
Northern Ireland and Scotland council areas, ie a big mess of various
things altogether in a category (as we wrote in the iso-codes
package).

We should probably pick a county to have a good example (for France, I
would pick one of our "Départements"....indeed, in the translation, I
picked my home city's Département).

I'm OK to put "Edinburgh, City of", of course..:-)


> so I'll assume that approach is standard and suggest the
> DefaultChoice value of "England" instead of "Some-State".

...or Scotland..:)

> Also: surely the obvious example organisation is example.org,
> instead of this "One Organization"?  What would they be doing
> spelling it like that anyway, if they're specifically in
> countryName=GB?  Okay, I wasn't going to, but I'm changing the
> DefaultChoice values.  Except for "countryName=GB" - it makes sense
> to remind users from the United Kingdom of Great Britain and
> Northern Ireland that they shouldn't use "UK", they have to follow
> the official slightly-broken ISO-3166 standard.

I slightly changed some:


>  Template: make-ssl-cert/statename
>  Type: string
> -_Default: Some-State
> -_Description: State or Province Name
> - Your state, county or province. (stateOrProvinceName)
> +_DefaultChoice: England

I finally used "Scotland" as a reward to the great Debconf we had.


> +_Description: State or province name:
> + Please enter the name of the political subdivision to use in the SSL
> + certificate.
> + .
> + It will become the 'stateOrProvinceName' field of the generated SSL
> + certificate.
>  
>  Template: make-ssl-cert/localityname
>  Type: string
> -_Default: Some-Locality
> -_Description: Locality Name
> - The name of the city or town that you live in. (localityName)
> +_DefaultChoice: Foo City

And "Edinburgh"

>  Template: make-ssl-cert/organisationname
>  Type: string
> -_Default: One Organization
> -_Description: Organisation Name
> - The name of the company or organisation the certificate is for.
> - (organisationName)
> +_DefaultChoice: Example.Org

In order to avoid users believe they should enter a domain name, I
used "Example Inc."


>  Template: make-ssl-cert/ouname
>  Type: string
> -_Default: One Organization Unit
> -_Description: Organisational Unit Name
> - The Division or section of the organisation the certificate is for.
> - (organisationalUnitName)
> +_DefaultChoice: Dept of Exemplification

I love that one but used "Dept. of Examplification"


Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature


Reply to: