[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: Kde-edu, GCompris, Gimp

Knut Yrvin wrote:

* Vidar Bakke

The only possible way to get the apps on the CD is
to replace some big existing packages. Replacement
candidates are:

With replace the LTSP that is based on RedHat today, and use the new
implementation, it could be possible to get 70 MB more space on the

If it's ready for production, lets replace it (although it only uses 58MB today) if not, lets replace it with lessdisks as it is in sarge today, it's widely used, and it works nicely.
lessdisks uses ~1MB

- the development tools (if needed apt-get install)

- emacs (not used by schools and redundant and
 it's only a quick apt-get install away)

I dont feel these two (dev-tools and emacs) are questionable anymore, so these will be gone on the next prerelease

I'll answer the "just use the apt-get anyway" idea. Unfortunately
there are schools in Norway that don't have broadband to do
apt-get. Then everything you need must be on the CD. Also users in
other countries has big limitations in bandwidth, and Skolelinux is
used there as well. Then it's of extreme importance that every tools
that prevents using the apt-get. I'll show to this issue discussed in
the Skolelinux project report from 20002 to the ministry of education
(translated to English):
 The Skolelinux project has to take in consideration that few schools
 has the band width that permits transferring big data volumes. That
 talked about in chapter 2.1.5 page [*], most of the schools have 64
 k-bit/s ISDN connection to the Internet. With that kind of
 limitation there are really important how the schools sets up
 temporary storages (proxy's). [...]


We also support schools in Norway with no or little network
connectively. 1/3 of the Norwegian schools don't have broadband. The
situation in other countries are not so bright either. In Africa they
ship mails by temperate storages that are taken bay moped to from the
school with Internet to the schools that have no Internet.

- Koffice (redundant and the cause of a lot
 of problems because of OOo mix up and it's
 better that a sys admin removes OOo and
 install Koffice to minimize end user problems
 if Koffice is their choice.
 Koffice is growing and has the same
 File, Edit, View, Insert, Format menu as OOo and
 for basic usage the same skill set is necessary.
 I consider Koffice redundant since OOo as of
 today is our preferred office suite. Personally
 I like Koffice better and I'm waiting for a better
 MS Word filter)

It's a good question because a lot of whats in the OpenOffice is never
in use in practical life. Why not use the Koffice-applications as
Kword which is popular in the lower grades (1-4) because it doesn't
have to complicated user interface. In lower grades the application
should be under-loaded with functionality. A lot of the pupils are
learning to handle complexity.
The compatibility with MS-formats is not good enough in koffice that is included in sarge. period. We need MSOffice compatible Office Suite. The closest we've got is OOo.

That said. After 4-5 year at the school, the pupils get older, more
educated in use of computer programs. Then OpenOffice is
introduced. It's bit like kids in general that starts with a tricycle,
and then go to a bicycle with helping wheels.

The real story here is that grown up expert applications that seems to
be general tools that everybody use, had a stiff learning curve. It's
to many menus for lower grade pupils. They use days to figure out the
menus before they can do anything. Grown ups tend to forget this. It's
like the cow that has forgot that here has been a cattle.

Thats why we should not use Evolution as a e-mail client, but a simple
web-mail client, or e.g Thunderbird / Kmail.
We dont include evolution, lets not include new apps into the CD before we've choosen which off the old one to keep.

What is the downsize of a possible package replacement?

I've got a lot of feedback that Gimp is just to complicated. Then
tuxpaint and kolourpaint are good candidates. They just do what you
want to to. The Gimp is even more "evil" than OpenOffice when it comes
to complicated menus. How could the kids make a rectangle with just a
push at the mouse without going through 3 menus?
Gimp is not ment for drawing circles and the like for pupils of lower grades. It's ment for manipulating existing images. If you want to have an example, look at http://www.holmlia.gs.oslo.no/index.php?artikkel=65

Also Koffice have good drawing applications both in koffice, and
OpenOffice.  There you get a rectangle with a push on the mouse
If the replacement is done the schools will have more
apps for learning purposes and the usefulness of
Skolelinux will increase.

I believe we should take away the applications that have to much
complexity in the menu structure. But removing the old LTSP will free
70 MB, and will help us removing applications to be less painful.
I Agree

// faj

Reply to: