[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#925530: cloud.debian.org: Debian docker images pointing to github for bug tracking

On 28/06/20 at 10:54 -0700, Ross Vandegrift wrote:
> [removing serpent@d.o from CC, he's resigned as delegate]
> Hi Lucas,
> On Sun, Jun 28, 2020 at 05:26:41PM +0200, Lucas Nussbaum wrote:
> > One could argue that the Cloud team delegation does not cover Docker
> > images.
> Whether it does or not, I've been told that the docker image maintainers prefer
> to keep their current organization and workflow.  I'd welcome their
> participation in the team, if they were interested.  But I don't think they
> need to be.

Well, I think that it would a good thing for Debian to enforce some
consistency on Debian images for clouds and software that require
VM images, at least about where to find information about such images,
and where to report problems.

And I don't think that pointing to github for our tooling, and for bug
reporting, is really an acceptable solution for something that is
officially endorsed by Debian.

Solving this for Docker or Vagrant sounds very similar to solving it for
cloud images; so it's probably best if the same people are in charge.

> Maybe it could be nice, if the people building those images want to use our
> tools and work with us.  Some would raise concerns in my mind, but I don't
> think it's useful to discuss before someone wants to build e.g. raspberry pi
> images in cloud-team.

I'm surprised by this. I thought of the delegation as a (soft) hammer to
enforce some rules, even when people are not nice and don't want to work
with the cloud team (I'm not saying it's the case here).

I've seen people saying "oh look, the official Debian images for docker
point to github! that's funnny!". If those images are not official,
then this should be clarified. If they are, then they should probably
conform to standard ways of maintaining stuff in Debian.


Reply to: